Subject: Don't confuse me with the facts my mind is made up!
From: Paul
Date: 2/6/2001, 12:37 PM


This is mainly for Klause Savier.  I thought you might be interested as well.

He keeps walking over to my hangar starting an argument about which is better...
the rotary or an air cooled aircraft engine. He acts like he is not interested
but it is he that comes over to my hangar to see what I am doing :-)

Paul Lamar

Ken Powell wrote:

Paul,
He probably really isn't interested in the rotary as an aircraft
engine - he's making a mint off the Lyncoming.  It's just that
your projects are of interest to anyone who likes mechanical
things.  -  Ken Powell


If I recall, from the time I visited you and spoke with him briefly, Klause has a theory (don't know where he got it) that I meant to throw out to the group.

He claims the rotary is subject to "metal migration" due to the fact that it fires 3 times per rotor revolution (almost continuous), when compared to the boinger's every other stroke.

Anyway, he claims that this "continuous firing" causes metals to be locally turned into plasma, which deposits out elsewhere in the engine, somewhere downstream.

I thought it was an interesting theory, with little validity, but did not want to scoff at him ... I respect his work, and thought there was a remote possibility that there might be some validity to the claim.

Even if true, would this not just be one more area of "wear"?

Any debunkers?
Dale

IMHO Klause is pulling your leg Dale :-) 

BTW the difference in souping up an aircraft piston engine compared to a car engine
is the aircraft engine is right out at the material limits for heat and 
strength. The cylinder heads run at a temperature right out at the limit for
aluminum. If you expect to get more HP out of an aircraft engine you must
also expect to get a shorter life, for, not only the cylinder heads, but every 
other part in the aircraft engine. The best materials for the job are used in 
aircraft engines and they run at the maximum allowable stress level for the 
expected life unlike a car piston engine where the cheapest materials are used 
commensurate with the car engines low duty cycle. 

This is done in aircraft engines to keep the weight as low as possible. An 
air cooled aircraft piston engine is a remarkably heavy duty piston engine 
for its weight. 

When you soup up a car engine you can buy aircraft quality parts for it 
such as 4140 cranks and 4130 rods to enhance the life with higher HP.

The Mazda rotary is an exception and I dread the day Ford forces Mazda to 
cheapen it up with... say... a cast iron e-shaft.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org