Subject: Non rotary: welding 4130
From: Paul
Date: 2/6/2001, 6:53 PM


SNIP:

Stay away from the MIG. It will not deliver
aircraft quality welds.  TIG or Oxy/actyl are the two choices.
Jerry

I'm not a welding expert but would be interested in understanding why MIG
won't provide quality workmanship on aircraft.  --  That's
practically all I
see them use at the race track.  Everyone keeps saying the same
thing, but
no one ever explains why.  If you can de-mystify this, those of us who
aren't certified welders would appreciate it :-)

Thanks,
Robin


As a Mechanical Engineer with just enough metalurgical experience to
make me
dangerous - I do not like MIG on anything with over "20" carbon, The
extremely
loal heating with this form of welding leads to very fast quenching at
the edge
of the weld zone, By the time you come back to "normalizing (not
really)" the
weld it is very likely to be too late, and micro cracking may allready
exist.
4130 is very forgiving, and a lot of people are getting away with it -
but not
on my engine mount please. - Vance


This is why I stay with my oxy-acetylene for 4130.   Makes good, safe, easy
to do welds that are very strong.   Cheap to buy, pretty easy to learn to use.
TIG can do the same thing Vance is talking about if misused by a non-expert
welder - in addition to the possible low penetration that they can do.  A
well done TIG weld is a thing of  beauty and very strong.   Use the correct
rod, too.

Bill
Long EZ builder & pilot
mechanical engineer

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org