Subject: Non rotary: welding 4130
From: Paul
Date: 2/7/2001, 11:24 PM


Hello guys,

    Everything you are saying is in general agreement with what Kent White
from TM Technologies teaches in conjunction with the EAA.  I started out
with a torch in my hand over 30 years ago and have always been in love with
the thing (AND IT'S DIRT CHEAP!) but when electric welding became
commercially available the good old torch just wasn't sexy anymore.  As far
as I can see, unless you're welding exotic metals the lowly old torch has
some advantages. -  Its heat radius and controlled cooling you mentioned
yourself.  Also, you can't light up a good cigar with a TIG torch :-)

    Once upon a time high quality fluxes were ubiquitous and dirt cheap too.
Today they're harder to find and the price has gone up too, but they do last
a long time.  The problem fluxes always had (besides a mess to clean up) was
"flare" during welding.  It's kind of like electric welding with a lens
that's not dark enough; the puddle is hard to see because of all the bright
light around it.  There is a new type of lens for gas welding called a
TM2000 that totally eleminates the problem though.  For those of you who
like myself got totally spoiled rotten by the automatically darkening
helmets for electric welding, the TM2000 will be a treat. -  All you see is
the puddle.  -  No flare at all, none...  Please be sure this is no
advertisement for Ken White or TM Technologies, but they are the ones who
patented the new lens and it works superbly (but it's a little pricey in my
opinion.)

    Anyway, I'm not an expert and I'm not certified, but I'm told that even
the extremely high priced TIG welders have certain drawbacks of their own.
I guess nothing is perfect.  I just don't understand why everyone wants to
buy the most expensive thing in the whole world when fairly inexpensive
tools can do the necessary job just as well.  (To me it's kind of like a
hundred thousand dollar IFR panel when you rarely fly IFR.)

    The important question that comes out of all of this is "how can we
teach new guys how to safely build airplanes?"  Some of us are building
pretty fancy airplanes, and some are building puddle jumpers on a budget.
Let's give the guys building on a budget all the help we extend to each
other on our high end stuff.  If there's a job they can safely do with a
hundred dollar torch vs. a twenty thousand dollar machine let's point them
towards somebody qualified to help them out.  I'm just as guilty as anybody,
but I think we scare a lot of good guys out of finishing their projects
because we park "Big Blue, or Big Red, or Old Yellow" beside our airplanes
and brag about what a fine job they do.  Perhaps we leave them believing
they have to own an entire machine shop to build their project and they just
give up and sell out, or worse yet, let it sit and rot away...

Just my $0.02 worth,
Robin

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org