Subject: Non rotary: welding 4130
From: Paul
Date: 2/7/2001, 11:35 PM


 > >> > Stay away from the MIG. It will not deliver
 >> >  > > > aircraft quality welds.  TIG or Oxy/actyl are the two choices.
 >> >  > > > Jerry


 >> >  > I'm not a welding expert but would be interested in understanding
 why MIG
 >> >  > won't provide quality workmanship on aircraft.  --  That's
practically
 >> all
 >> > I
 >> >  > see them use at the race track.  Everyone keeps saying the
same thing,
 >> but
 >> >  > no one ever explains why.  If you can de-mystify this,
those of us who
 >> >  > aren't certified welders would appreciate it :-)
 >> >  >
 >> >  > Thanks,
 >> >  > Robin


 >> The MIG (metallic Inert Gas) welder is just fine for non heat treatable
 >> alloys and some aluminum. The rate of deposit and rate of cooling is very
 >> fast. On low carbon steels this is a good weld, since there
will be little
 >> strength lost from rapid cooling. You can weld mild (low
carbon) steel, and
 >> drop it into cold water without causing a problem. This is not
the case with
 >> SAE 4130 and others. On thicker pieces the material should be
warmed before
 >> welding and covered, or dropped into a lime box to cool very
slowly. On thin
 >> wall tubing the problem is much worse. A breath of air can chill the weld
 >> area quickly enough to install a near random selection of treated zones
 >> across the weld area. If TIG (Tungsten Inert Gas) is being
used, the joint
 >> should be reheated and cooled very slowly. This can be done by
covering the
 >> joint with a drape of nonflammable material (not touching the work). The
 >> reheat would include the weld and the tubing out from welded
area for an inch
 >> or inch and a half. Gas welding is so slow that a large area is
heated just
 >> doing the weld, so all that is left is the drape and slow cooling. This
 >> returns the material to close to the as shipped, annealed condition.
 >> Lynn E. Hanover

 Technically, 4130 is supplied 'normalized' rather than annealed.  The
 difference is subtle, but basically it is pretty hard to keep from getting
 some extra
 hardness and strength above annealed without going to heroic (silly) super
 slow cooling rates.  Normailzed is stronger than truly annealed, but 4130 is
 hard to actually anneal (dead soft) so it is normalized.  IIRC, 60ksi yield
 in the normalized condition with 30% elongation to failure.   This is 4130's
 big advantage - it will bend a LOT before breaking.  I like that in aircraft
 structures.  Anything like a normal cooling rate will cause significant
 hardening in 4130, with loss of ductility, but a gain in yield strength.
 This again
 supports  oxy-acetylene welding as you can easily play the torch over the
 weld (a neutral flame provides heat and a reasonably effective blanket
 against oxidation) and slowly draw it away to keep the cooling rate low.
 Lynn is correct about drafts being pretty bad on thin walled tubing welds.
 Weld indoors away from drafts. Esp in the winter.   Good safe 4130 welds
 are not difficult with oxy-acetylene, but there are some do's and don't's.
 Get and use FAA Pub. AC43.13-1A &2A (now 1B & 2B, I think)

 Bill
 Long EZ builder & pilot
 > mechanical engineer

To Lynn and Bill,  I would like to include your comments in a
newsletter I publish for Tailwind builders, with you permission, of
course.

  Jerry Hey

  j-winddesigns@thegrid.net

I don't mind either Jerry. Just give us a plug.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org