Leon Promet wrote:
Hi Paul,
Leon the Lunatic here again. Just crawled out of his antipodean cave for a
spell. I am on short finals right now, and don't have a lot of time, but
I just CAN'T resist rising to this bait!! Without further ado!!
SNIP >>
I see three serious problems right off the bat with the BWB.
A: The fuel locations is well aft of the CG.
##
So that means that as the fuel is used, the CofG moves FORWARD, and makes
the thing MORE stable!! It also means that in a prang, the fuel gets left
behind the passengers so they don't end up as roast "long pork"!! That's
the whole Burnelli concept. Keep the fuel well away from the fleshy stuff
and the blow torches, and if perchance, a fuel cell happens to rupture,
it gets left BEHIND the fuselage, not UNDER and around it!!.
B: What happens when you fly at 400 MPH into a 5000 FPM updraft
with all that wing area?
What happens indeed? Doesn't this sort of performance have something to
do with wing LOADING, rather than just "all that wing area"? You, of all
people should understand that?? Any idea of the wing loading Paul, ...
anybody?? I have no idea.
All Boeing are doing are putting to work the patented Burnelli principle of
converting the parasitic drag producing surface area of the fuselage into
lift producing wing area. Given approximately the same, maybe a BIT less
wing loading, I'd expect approximately the same performance in a violent
up draft, given similar wing loadings. I can also see that the wing would
be somewhat stronger than a 777, and there would be less chance of
catastrophic failure.
C: How do you evacuate 500 pax quickly in an emergency or crash?
Easy. Have a look at the Boeing site for details. Moreover, the 500 pax
will have a much better chance to survive the crash landing and the de
rigeuer fire and subsequent asphyxiation by toxic fumes that usually seems
to accompany a crash landing in conventional aircraft. At least there
isn't a pencil fuselage to bust open, and the passengers are not sitting
on a JP bomb (if you believe the TWA 800 enquiry!!)! Lots of good info on
www.aircrash.org for those who do not suffer from deep seated prejudices,
and concrete minds!!
Is one of these really better than two 777's and if so why?
Paul, if you are really serious in answering this question, may I
respectfully suggest that it IS now time you went to www.aircrash.org and
read through the WHOLE website. I wonder what the glide characteristics of
a fully laden 777 are when you turn the noise off??
If the cruise wing loading is the same then the 747 has a BIG BIG advantage
because of the fowler flaps which are IMPOSSIBLE to install
on a flying wing.Fowler flaps typically double the lift coefficient.
Obviously the wing loading is much much less on
the flying wing so therefor the gust response is much much worse.
No! You read the book on Northrop and Horton Brothers flying wings.
And NO the Burnelli is not a flying wing %$#^&*
Forget the stupid Burnelli :-) :-) :-)
Paul Lamar