Hans,
I definitely want a set of Apex Seals for my 20B, but I'm hoping to get a
little information from you and the group first. My 20B engine just arrived
and I will be picking it up from the shipping company in a couple of days.
Until now, I've been trying to collect all the information possible in
preparation for its arrival. I have never seen or worked on a rotary engine
before (although I have extensive experience with piston engines) so please
excuse me if this sounds very elementary or plain stupid:
First, I was not planning to have my rotors machined for 3mm Apex Seals. I
heard from several builders that it was not necessary, and I was all for the
idea of trying to avoid the additional machining and shipping cost that it
would take to have this done. Can someone tell me what is to be gained by
going to 3mm Apex Seals for an aircraft application?
According to Hurley:
better control at high RPM
4% more BHP at high RPM
Other gains would be increase resistance to detonation induced damage, likely not critical in a naturally aspirated engine.
Personally, I would stick to the cheaper seal sets in 2mm in a non turbocharged application, so what if you lose 4% HP? Just think of the money you save. Plus machining the rotors is very hard, actually grinding them appears to be the thing to do.
Is it really worth
doing? How does the Hurley Seals compare to what you can buy locally at say
Atkins or Mazdatrix?
Not sure about Atkins, he may sell Hurley apex seals, the comparison, again according to Hurley:
Kinder on rotor housing (softer than standard Mazda) which means better sealing, faster break in and higher compression than the harder mazda seals on used rotor housing.
Another advantage: Much cheaper.
Eamon makes the point that the old "one piece" apex seals used in the 12A never used to break, and he thinks mazda went backwards with the newer multi piece design
Are the apex seals the same as what you are calling the
tip seals?
Yes.
Second, is it typically necessary to replace the side seals. If so, what is
the best source for these, or, do they come as a set with the Apex Seals?
Not really necessary. Currently only mazda ones are available. One reason to replace: It can be hard to get the old ones out without bending them.
Third, what else will I need to rebuild my 20B assuming that the housings and
rotors are all OK? I'm assuming a gasket set and the Apex Seals, but what
else should be replaced while I'm in there?
My opinion, in addition to gaskets and Apex seals: Corner seal springs, corner seal plugs, side seal springs.
Do the bearings typically need
to be replaced?
No.
I would appreciate any info that the group members can provide!!
That would be good as I am no expert. See the Hurley website at:
http://www.hurley-engineering.ltd.uk/
Hans Conser
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org