Subject: The 4130 and mig issue
From: Paul
Date: 2/14/2001, 10:44 PM

Peter Cowan/Lexi Cameron wrote:

Thanks very much to all of you who responded to this. Lonnie's and Jerry's comments about the vertical alignment jogged me because I hadn't addressed that well enough.

I wonder if some of the negative comments on mig stem from the quality of some early machines. The first one I bought over ten years ago had extremely poor penetration. Most welds looked like I'd layed down rope on top. When I asked a local welder what I was doing wrong, he said that many machines just did not have the output that they were rated at. I sold it and bought a Lincoln 170 and it is a totally different machine that produces much better penetration.

 So what is the net of all your comments? I did dig out my Dillon torch and used it as well as mig to do some test welds which I attempted to break. Not to precise, but I couldn't see much differance in how they broke: outside of the weld itself.

Would I be way off base to conclude that especially with a sleeved repair I can get more than adequate strength using mig? Actually, I think I'll use the technique that Jery mentioned: a combination of gas and mig and re-heating mig welds to check for penetration.

One other issue: Is there anything wrong with mig wire as welding rod? I find that 035 or 045 melts very readily with acetylene welding.

Thanks again for all the input.
Peter.

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org