Subject: Rotary mania in R&T
From: Paul
Date: 2/23/2001, 4:30 PM
CC: Dennis Simanaitis

Bill Freeman wrote:

Paul,

 OK, I can't wait any longer.  Apparently nobody else on this whole
car and airplane crazy newsletter gets Road & Track!  The latest issue
is jam packed with rotary info and not a peep.

They have a nice article on the RX8 and a Paul Frere re-test drive
of the Lemans winning Mazda racer.   I thought I'd let somebody
else break the news but after about two weeks, I couldn't stand
it any more.

Bill

OK I got the magazine. I was very disappointed and unsatisfied  with both articles. 
I think I could do a much better job of providing technical background.
R&T should have used some engine illustrations from SAE paper 920309
"Mazda 4-Rotor rotary Engine for the Le Mans
24-Hour Endurance Race" written by Mazda engineers.
Below is an illustration from that paper.

The 787B article made it sound like Mazda had tried to win Le Mans
for 18 years when in fact they did not build the four rotor till 1990.
Prior to that they ran two rotor engines at Le Mans I think.
You are not going to win Le Mans with a 2600 CC rotary engine derived from 
a passenger car engine running against 3 liter and up pure racing engines
rotary or no rotary. Besides, the rules favor piston engines when a minimum 
car weight is specified and as I recall that is and was the case at Le Mans.
One of the big advantages of the rotary engine is its excellent power 
to weight ratio. If the car is not designed with that in mind the 
engine has a handicap. 

For example in the R&T RX8 article the estimated weight is 3500 pounds.
The wheelbase is given at 106 inches. I looked up the weight of some
other four door cars with about the same wheel base and the weight of those
cars was not anywhere near 3500 pounds. A BMW 328 is 3170 pounds for one example. 
If Mazda  can not bring the RX8 in at less than 3000 pounds with a 200 pound 
250 HP rotary engine I would be very much surprised. This is going to have an
enormous effect on the acceleration.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org