Subject: Wankelsaurus vs Deltavapor vs Lycotech (I know, I'm getting old)]
From: Paul
Date: 3/9/2001, 10:53 AM


The Mazda weighs 190 pounds less the PSRU and about 240 with. Up to
215 HP normally aspirated and 250 HP or so turbo for another 50 pounds
or so. Turbo race engines are putting out 900 HP without coming apart.

The casting technique can be the best in the world but if the block wall
thickness is not thick enough it will flex. One of the reasons
most diesels are made with cast iron and are heavy for their HP
is the cylinder pressures are much higher than in a piston engine.
The stiffness to weight ratios for metals is all about the same so the
wall thickness of aluminum blocks must be much thicker to get
the required stiffness. A point frequently overlooked by engine designers.
Not only that but the crank, pistons  and rods have to be stronger and
heavier.
The weight for the DeltaHawk sounds low. Therein probably lie their
problems.

Paul Lamar

Manta Flight Systems wrote:

Since the Mazda is so light, why do all the planes that use a Mazda seem to
have a higher empty weight then the same model plane with a heavy Lyc?  They
also seem to all be slower even though they claim to have more HP.  Maybe
someone can add some insight into this?

I think Ford and Mazda did work hard to make the fuel mileage better for the
new RX8 but there are many ways to increase mileage even if the engine is a
fuel hog.  The best method is to make the car itself lighter then the
competition.

I also checked the DeltaHawk web page and they seem to have a problem with
math.  If you use their numbers for SFC the Lyc will burn 9.1 gal/hr at 65%
(they give 10 gal/hr) and the DeltaHawk will burn 7.7 gal/hr (they give 7.0
gal/hr).  I also don't understand how they get a 2000 hour TBO when the
engine has never run in real world use.  It is easy to post a few numbers to
a web page but much harder to produce the same numbers in the real world.

I wish them luck but at least they should try to get the math right.

Mark

OK, I will shut up now.

I don't know where you got your info on the aircraft weight. 
Most people say their rotary powered aircraft weigh the same as a O-320 or O-360
including the liquid cooling system. The Power Sport RV4 rotary had the fastest 
time to climb at Sun & Fun a couple of years ago and went 238 MPH in the Sun 
100 race. Tracy Crook is now going 220 MPH in his RV4. Hopefully we will have 
several rotary entries in this years Sun 100 race. The ACRE NL has put up $500 
cash prize for the fastest rotary powered airplane over 200 MPH.

Most faster aircraft engine entries are souped up somehow. Usually by running them 
over the RPM red line. This is, of course, at the expense of TBO. Klause Saviour 
has dropped a valve and broken a piston pin on two different occasions. Tracy 
Saylor overhauled his LyCon engine at 450 hours. I have no idea how often Dave Anders 
overhauls his 260 HP Lyc IO-360 but I will ask next time I see him. The rotary 
will eventually run these aircraft engine powered airplanes into the ground as they
have done so in world wide car racing. They are just plain unfair to a piston engine :-)

Paul Lamar