Subject: Wankelsaurus vs Deltavapor vs Lycotech (I know, I'm getting old)
From: Paul
Date: 3/10/2001, 4:09 PM


The weight for the DeltaHawk sounds low. Therein probably lie their
problems.
Paul Lamar

Manta Flight Systems wrote:
I also checked the DeltaHawk web page and they seem to have a problem with
math.  If you use their numbers for SFC the Lyc will burn 9.1 gal/hr at
65%
(they give 10 gal/hr) and the DeltaHawk will burn 7.7 gal/hr (they give
7.0
gal/hr).  I also don't understand how they get a 2000 hour TBO when the
engine has never run in real world use.  It is easy to post a few numbers
to
a web page but much harder to produce the same numbers in the real world.
Mark

I know this isn't exactly rotary related, but I live in Racine, and I've
seen the Deltahawk diesel engine in action.  The local EAA chapters (mine
included) have quite of bit of interest in this engine for obvious reasons.

The numbers are correct, but their easier to understand when you stop and
think about the fact that this engine is a -diesel-.  Diesel fuel, and
Jet-A, has more latent (I don't know what the correct term is, BTU/lbs)
power than "gas".  The diesel combustion process is also more efficient than
the typical gas piston engine.  So yes, a Lyc will burn 9.1 gal/hr of
"100LL" at 65%, and a Deltahawk will burn 7.0 gal/hr of "Jet-A" at 65%.  Not
exactly the same thing, but true enough.

It is unlikely it is burning 7 and generating the same power.
Lets  say the Delta Hawk BSFC is really bad  for a diesel at 0.45. 
Seven gallons times 6.6 pounds per gallon for diesel fuel is 46 pounds an hour.
Divided by .45 is 102 HP. Lets say it is a Lyc O-320 with 160 HP therefor
 65% max HP is 104 HP. That gives the Lyc a BSFC of  0.53 based on six pounds
per gallon for gasoline. The burn is not likely to be that high at 65% cruise power
on a Lyc. I think that is what Mark was referring to as far as the bad math is 
concerned. Lyc's at cruise have a BSFC about .45 so the burn should be only 7.8 
gallons per hour and not 9.1 gallons per hour.

A good diesel on the other hand has a BSFC of 0.38. Apparently this is a bad diesel 
and apparently DeltaHawk is exaggerating the burn of the Lyc to make the DeltaHawk 
look good. I am not surprised as a loop scavenged two cycle diesel is not going to be
very efficient. A lot of raw fuel will merely blow out the exhaust. 

BTW This is one way of doing the numbers but it would help if I knew the claimed 
HP and BSFC for the Delta Hawk. PL
  

As far as the engine, from what I've seen, the engine should be strong
enough to handle just about anything.  I don't have any exact numbers, but
the piston walls were conciderably thicker than what I've seen on a O-300 or
O-320 jug.  The main issue I see with the Deltahawk diesel is that it's
monoblock construction.  No jugs to replace, which can be a good thing and a
bad thing I suppose.

For the same stiffness the walls would have to be three times thicker
than steel. The density of steel is .3 pounds per cubic inch and that
of aluminum is .1 pound per cubic inch. The modulas of elasticity 
for steel is 30 million. That of aluminum is 10 million.  The weight 
would then be the same as steel cylinders. PL


The last time that I was at the Deltahawk hanger, they were starting
production, with a production run of 25 engines in process.  None of the
engines were for planes though.

My biggest concern isn't whether or not Deltahawk will make a lightweight
diesel engine, in my opinion, they've already done that.  My concern is
whether or not they will be successful in satisfying FAA requirements (my
translation: ego's) to get the engine certified.

The story that the owner tells about the engine eventually comes around to
the fact that he's received far more calls for the engine for non-aviation
purposes than for actually putting in a plane.  As he puts it, he informs
any potential customer that the engine is for "aircraft", and as such, is
very expensive.  He still has more customers than he has production, and he
wont have the liability of having the engine installed in a plane.  One of
the examples that he gave out was hovercraft.  One of the possible
applications he talks about is a marine hovercraft manufacturer that is
waiting for him to supply as many engines as he can produce for sale in S.
America.  4 or 8 engines on each boat to allow transport of goods.

Meanwhile, the engines that Deltahawk is trying to get through the FAA are
running into issues.  One example is the removal of fuel injection.
Apparently, someone from the FAA didn't want fuel injection on the engine,
to the point that they wouldn't certify the engine if fuel injection were
used.

If you could sell every engine that you could produce for ~20K to market
segments that had historically limited liability concerns and very few
regulatory problems, why bother with aviation?  That's my concern, and it
wouldn't be the first engine to go that route.

Sorry for the extra long babble.

    Rob Luce

Why are they bothering to certify it? That does not make sense. Why not sell it
to the experimental aircraft market. Not much about Delta Hawk makes sense. Frankly 
I don't buy any of it. I suppose they are selling stock too. I can't tell if they
are a scam or just ignorant. There are a lot of ignorant buyers out there too 
with "DIESEL" stamped in their forehead.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org