G'day Paul,
This is becoming a can of worms! See comments below marked ##.
SNIP >>
It is an old obsolete drawing. Put the starter on the plug side next to the
redrive
and not next to the engine. Keep it lower than the top of the engine
so it will clear a low cowl. PL
##
Maaaaaaaaaaaaaate, why would you give me an obsolete drawing? What I
really require is a proper drawing with all the dimensions so that I can
give it to a machinist to punch into a CNC. If I give them this stuff,
they are going to laugh at me, and tell me to stop being a wanker, and
get my act together! {:>)
##
As it is, I now have to go up to Jeff, and say "Sorry mate, the Yank
sent me an obsolete drawing. Ignore it. The starter goes on the other
side!!" So can you please, please give me an accurate drawing of EXACTLY
what you want? I'm happy to make anything you want, (I'll do my own thing
as a separate project), and I'm happy do all the detail webbing and
gusseting design, which I will clear with you before committing it to
alloy..
##
I deal with machinists all the time. They don't think like you and I.
That's why they are machinists, and not designers! They want proper ISO
drawings. I have to sign off on them. Then, if they make a mistake, and
the product doesn't match the drawing, they pay, materials , the lot.
##
However, if I have made a mistake in the drawings, then I pay. It's as
simple as that. I have NO intention of ending up with several thousand
dollars worth of scrap alloy and lumps of artfully crafted wood desperately
trying to masquerade as PSRU adaptors!.
##
BTW, some time ago , you had a shot at me about my knowledge about Henry
Ford and mass production principles. I replied that I did indeed understand
about maximum and minimum material conditions, and machining error limits
and tolerances. Chickens do often come home to roost! Check ... ! (and
mate in two moves!) {:>)
SNIP >>
Here is what Tracy said and I can confirm these dimensions as I have one of
his redrives. Ignore those drawings I sent you Leon. This is what counts.
##
Maaaaaaaaate, the dimensions that Tracey has given me below don't have ANY
tolerances on them. If you want it to fit, there must be tolerances
within which the machinist has to work. If I am to put the register on
the bell housing to locate the PSRU, I need to know what it's MAXIMUM
material condition will be, so that I can make the INSIDE of the register
so that it will fit at MINIMUM material condition. If it is too tight, it
won't fit, and if it's a slop fit, then it might as well not be there.
##
As discussed when you were here, if it isn't concentric with the eccentric
shaft, then you end up with lateral loads on the bearings, and it imparts
an orbital motion on the vibration damper.. That's why bell housings have
accurate location dowels. The PSRU MUST have the same thing. It must be
concentric with the engine output shaft. Same goes for the 12 holes.
"For Paul, Leon & others doing their own redrive adapters, the diameter of
the bolt circle is 5.875". The pattern is 12 holes (1/4" diameter, 30
degrees apart) with the top two holes 15 degrees either side of the 12:00
position. The center hole for the input shaft is 1.010" . The counter
bore for the input shaft oil seal is 1.500" dia. and depth is .310, bored
from the engine side. Starter hole is 2.675" in diameter and center to
center distance (from input shaft hole) is 6.700"."
##
OK, I'm not trying to be difficult, but as soon as I give this to a
machinist, first thing he is going to ask me is "What is the tolerance on
the PCD? 1 thou, 5 thou. 10 thou?" (Remember, I worked next door to a
gear cutter for 10 years, so I got to know how they think!!).
##
Further, what are the hole size tolerances, especially seeing that
without a machined register, that's all that aligns the PSRU to the
eccentric shaft. Are the holes and the bolts size for size, interference
fit, clearance holes. what bolts are specified? What shank size. OK,
they are nominal 1/4 inch, but is that 0.2500, 0.2490, 0.2495 or what?
##
Using the register idea, the bolt holes sizes are no longer critical, and
can be clearance holes, but if the bolts are being used as location
devices, then they had better be size for size. If they are size for
size, then the pitch circles have very little tolerance for either
concentricity, or actual diameter. I'm not trying to be difficult, but
as I said before, peoples' lives are going to be hanging off these things,
so it had to be 100% correct.
Tracy, we need one more dimension and that is the overall OD of the redrive
so Leon can put a locating recess in his bell housing. Sort of a large
counter
bore. I figure it to be about 6 and 9/16th OD but we need the actual
dimension
down to the nearest .001 inch.
##
Maybe the best way is for Tracey to send me a BARE machined PSRU housing
(an a sample oil seal) so that I can give it to the machinist and just say
"here, make this fit, and make it concentric". Best way, ... then the
monkey is on the Machinist's back!! I'm more than happy to sign a
confidentiality/non-disclosure agreement with Tracey, and promise I won't
copy his PSRU design. I can then machine up a mandrel to check for
concentricity of the bell housings, using the PSRU housing and a dummy
engine block as a gauge tool.
##
Whenever I do bell housings or adaptors, a mandrel is made up to go in the
engine main bearing tunnel and the gearbox case mainshaft tunnel so that
everything is concentric. If I have an exemplar PSRU housing, I can check
the bell housings for concentricity and register size before they are
shipped. If the machined product doesn't fit perfectly on the engine
dowels, then it goes back from whence it came. This is called quality
control! (Something Good Ole Henry and his successors have always been a
bit short on! }:>)).
##
Cheers mate!
Leon