Subject: Design & Weight of Bell Housing was RE: Cast bell housing Take 5
From: Paul
Date: 3/20/2001, 10:38 PM

Leon Promet wrote:

Hi Paul,

Very simple Leon. It becomes redundant to specify tolerances as
modern NC mills are what they are.

Mate,  I am sure that sometimes we live in a different planet. (Maybe we
just have a different way of doing engineering Down Under!  We do machine
in metric here).  An NC machine is not some magic device that automatically
produces perfect product.

The NC machine is still only as good as the tool setter.  The tighter the
tolerances,  the more care has to be exercised.  Tooling does wear,
machines develop slop in them, and 6061 castings are definitely not the
nicest stuff in the world to machine.  Two things are at issue here.
 Absolute size,  and repeatability.

You put in .1874 in the NC program and that is what you get to the
best of the NC mills ability. Usually .0005.

Sounds good ... in theory!!!  So is that:  0.1874 +/- 0.0005,  or is it
0.1874 + 0.000 / - 0.0005 or 0.001?  Or is it 0.1874 + 0.001 / - 0.0000?

Once I do get a machined sample,  I need to measure it to make sure it is
within specs.  What specs?  Well ... that's where tolerancing comes on.
 The tighter we hold the tolerances,  the more it will cost to machine..

See,  I'm the one who will have the problems if they don't fit once they
get over your way. . So if you can,  please just send me a bare PSRU
machined case as a sample, and I'll just make the sucker fit. Easy.  All I
am trying to do is ensure no cock-ups!  (Professor Murphy is alive and well
on Planet Earth!!).

Cheers,

Leon Promet
peon@pacific.net.au

I think you are making more out of this than necessary Leon. With twelve 
bolts things tend to average out even if the holes are oversize.
Never the less I will ask Tracy.

Tracy, what tolerances do you use? Will you ship the mating part in
question to Leon?

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org