Subject: Design & Weight of Bell Housing was RE: Cast bell housing Take 3
From: Paul
Date: 3/21/2001, 10:32 AM


Todd Carrico wrote:

Paul Lamar:
Very simple Leon. It becomes redundant to specify tolerances as
modern NC mills are what they are.

You put in .1874 in the NC program and that is what you get to the
best of the NC mills ability. Usually .0005.

Todd Carrico:
<QA>
That is probably an over simplification.  Lots of things go into the
finished part, such as rigidity of the fixture holding the part, tool
wear,
tool offsets (to compensate for tool wear), Multi-step operations where
you
have to remove the part and reposition it.  Just because the machine is
capable of moving a tool to within .00005 of where you want it, doesn't
mean
that your part will have that kind of accuracy.  Murphy has a lot to do
with
it.
</QA>

I think that properly thought out dimensions add a professional touch.
If
you are worried about how much time it takes, you can specify a general
standard (say +/- .010) and then for special areas specify a tighter
tolerance.  This will give the machinest some flexability in how they
fixture the part.  It also gives you some leverage if they can't make a
part
that is suitable.

tc

This is not rocket science we are doing here guys. There is a certain
amount of
flexibility in the input shaft in the form of two splines and a pilot hole
that may vary in size depending on how the old needle bearings were
removed. At least
I think the pilot hole is used. I forgot for sure. Tracy do you use the
pilot hole in the end of the e-shaft? If not the pilot hole..... the
input shaft end is located by four RUBBER bushings!

Paul Lamar


Tracy Crook wrote:


By now I'm sure it is abundantly clear to everyone just how complicated
relatively simple changes can be.

Be assured that the input shaft on the RD-1(A/B) drive is positively located
on both ends.  The input end is piloted into the recess in the engine shaft.
Note that the needle bearing used on manual transmissions must be removed
from the recess for the input shaft to be installed.  Just to eliminate
anymore warnings sent my way about how there should be a bearing there,
remember that there is no relative rotation at this point so just grease it
and install.  The other end of the input shaft is piloted by a pressure
lubricated plain bearing riding on the prop shaft.  I've answered many
comments (not from Paul) about how this seems like a flimsy way to support
the input shaft radial loads.  There ARE NO radial loads on a planetary
drive input shaft.

I specified a tolerance of + or - .001 on the twelve 1/4" holes.  The CNC
shop that makes the planet carrier housings (the part that mates to the
adapter plate) does an excellent job and the actual precision is better than
I am able to measure at my shop.   As long as the precision of the adapter
plate and planet carrier housing is correct, I have always gotten good
registration by allowing them to self center on the 12 holes.  The squeezing
of the required silicon gasket sealer (between planet carrier housing &
adapter plate) into the small gaps appears to enhance the self-centering
effect.  Haven't found any significant runout on the 6 that I tested.

On the diameter of the planet carrier housing, It is nominally 6.75", but
this is not a tightly controlled dimension since it is non critical and
every tight tolerance specified adds cost.  The exact OD has been different
on each batch of planet carrier housings.   Sorry.  If someone wants to turn
the housing down to a tightly specified dimension, be my guest.  The 12
holes ARE perfectly concentric (+ or - .001") with the housing OD however.
This being the case, sending this part to Leon would not serve any real
purpose.

In a previous message someone mentioned different length input shafts and
implied that I said it is not a problem.  True, it is not a technical
problem but remember that this does not mean that it is low cost or fast.
"One of a kind" parts tend to be more expensive and take time.  YOU (the
builder) must decide if cost or delivery schedule is a problem.

I furnish the 12 AN4-47A bolts for mounting the drive but remenber that they
are sized for going through my 1/2" adapter plate.  If the new adapter is
thicker, longer bolts will be required.  Be sure you are sitting down when
you check the price of longer bolts.

By all means, EXPERIMENT!  Just remember Det. Callahan's words of wisdom.

Tracy Crook
tcrook@rotaryaviation.com
www.rotaryaviation.com

The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org