BTW what is intrinsically wrong with cruising at 6000 RPM?
It sure is easy to get a lot more power at 7000 RPM then it is
at 6000 RPM. A lot of the gyro guys running rotaries are running 2.85:1
PSRU ratios with multi blade Warp Drive props. They don't seem to have
any engine problems.
Paul Lamar
Mike Wills wrote:
Paul,
This looks like a simple math problem to me so explain to me where I've
gone wrong. The RVs are designed around 150 - 180HP Lycs. That means
takeoff RPM (prop) of 2700 and cruise at 2300 - 2500 usually. Most RVers
are flying with props in the 68" - 72" diameter range and with a pitch
appropriate for the HP without over-revving. If you want to have the best
chance of matching (or exceeding) the published RV performance figures that
is how you are going to have to prop the airplane. So working backwards
from that with a 2.85 PSRU would seem to suggest an engine RPM of 7700
takeoff/climb and 6550 - 7125 at cruise. Presumably you would want to tune
the 13B to optimize performance at those RPMs. I agree that turning that
kind of RPM should result in some serious HP. Probably some pretty serious
fuel consumption as well !!
Cruising at 6000 engine RPM as you suggest means a prop RPM of 2100. I'm
no prop expert (far from it) but to me this suggests a larger diameter prop
to maintain efficiency and equal (or better) the performance of an RV
turning a smaller prop @ 2300 - 2500 as described above. As Tracy points
out this isnt possible in the real world.
Again I'm no expert but I had always thought adding blades or blade width
is not the way to go for a performance application. All the fast guys
flying RVs are flying 2 blade props as mentioned above. I dont see where
the examples of gyro guys with their Warp drive props applies to the
discussion. Their experience may suggest something about durability of the
13B but I dont see where it says anything about the performance potential
of a fast airframe (like an RV) with that type of prop. The only guy I know
of flying a multi-blade Warp drive on an RV is Jess Meyers on his Chevy
powered RV6A. I believe he claims somewhere around 230HP out of that engine
but his airplane performs comparably with an overweight 160HP RV6A.
Now I suppose a guy could spend a lot of trial and error time trying
different sorts of home made wood props. After enough iterations you may
even match Tracy's performance. I cant speak for anyone else but after 5+
years of building I've had about enough experimentation on this particular
airframe. Its time to get this thing done, get it in the air, and prove to
all those naysayers that I can match the performance of their Lyc powered
birds. Maybe after its flying I'll find that I cant match that performance
without some further tweaking but at this point I think I have a far better
chance by doing what I know works for others.
Mike Wills
Wait a minute. I said max RPM 7000 cruise 6000 and nothing about a stock prop :-)
All you need do is add blade area and pitch. What is the big deal
about that? Also three blades are only slightly less efficient than two blades.
Probably down around 1 or 2%. It all depends on what you want to do.
To me just getting up in the air is not enough. I am looking to push
the edges of the envelope. Yes if you just want to get up in the air copy
Tracy exactly. How boring :-) Anyway by the time mine is flying Butch
will have the variable pitch prop done for sure knowing Butch.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org