Subject: 2.85:1 psru ratio
From: Paul
Date: 3/30/2001, 7:25 PM


Wait a minute. I said max RPM 7000 cruise 6000 and nothing about a stock
prop :-)

All you need do is add blade area and pitch. What is the big deal
about that? Also three blades are only slightly less efficient than two
blades.
Probably down around 1 or 2%. It all depends on what you want to do.
To me just getting up in the air is not enough. I am looking to push
the edges of the envelope. Yes if you just want to get up in the air copy
Tracy exactly. How boring :-) Anyway by the time mine is flying Butch
will have the variable pitch prop done for sure knowing Butch.

Paul Lamar


Paul,

  I understood EXACTLY what you said. I believe it is you who misunderstood
my point. So let me try again. There are approximately 2500 RVs of various
sorts flying at this point in time, almost all (certainly all the fastest
guys) turning 2 bladed props at approximately 2700RPM at takeoff power.
Those 2 bladed props are in the 68 - 72" diameter range with the max
diameter established by ground clearance. Those 2500 airplanes establish a
pretty solid benchmark for performance. I want my airplane to at least
equal and hopefully exceed that benchmark.

  Now add a variable by changing engines. If the engine you change to can
be geared to provide about the same amount of power at the same prop RPM as
those 2500 other guys then I'd say its reasonable to expect comparable
performance. Its also relatively easy to go to any one of at least a dozen
prop builders, tell them you have an RV whatever with X amount of
horsepower, tell them you want a prop that will provide 2300 static RPM,
2700RPM max, and you will likely end up with a combination that performs as
expected (assuming you are realistic when you estimate the HP).

  Add another variable by limiting prop RPM to 2450 max and cruise RPM of
2100 (I was always taught 1 variable at a time, establish a benchmark, then
add another variable). Your still limited by ground clearance so a bigger
prop isnt an option. So you have to add area or pitch or both. Your in
uncharted territory when it comes to building a prop for this
configuration. Go to those same prop builders, tell them you have an RV
whatever and tell them what you want the prop to do. Your far less likely
to get what you need because none of them have ever built such a prop for
an RV before. You may spend the next 5 years tweaking props trying to match
that benchmark set by the 2500 other guys before you.

  So I think my original thinking on this still holds. If you are going to
fly an RV and you want to equal or better Van's performance figures and you
want to do that as effortlessly as possible, it seems to me that it better
be propped the way RVs are typically propped. Which means if you are
running a 2.85 PSRU you better be prepared to really wind the engine. This
is why I ( and I think Tracy) chose the 2.17 PSRU.

  I'd say Tracy has done more than "just gotten in the air". My airplane
certainly is no copy of Tracy's but if it performs as well as his does out
of the box I'll be ecstatic. Boring???

Mike Wills


Mike I fully understand all that but things have changed in the
prop business lately. Don Bates and others have done a wonderful job
writing programs that accurately predict the performance of props.
No way should it take five years. http://www.innercite.com/~bateseng/

Don did the prop for Charlie Airesman direct drive Subaru doing 200 MPH
in a Varieze. If Don did that surely he can cope with 25 HP more
from a rotary and a bit less prop RPM.

I think we are unnecessarily handicapping the rotary engine by using 2.17:1 
psru's and 6000 RPM max. I know we can get much more HP at 7000 RPM. All we 
need is a new prop and a 2.85:1 PSRU. Why settle for something just as good 
as a Lycoming when we can have something better? There is nothing hard 
about this.

Jerry Bass has a 2.85:1 psru and an RV6A and he is going to show us the way!
Aren't you Jerry? :-) I predict it will happen in the next six months.

Somebody on here as I recall already has Don's program.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org