marc wiese wrote:
Misalignment between the groove machined in the rotor and the groove in the
corner seal can cause pressurization of the "crankcase". It takes very
little pressure to blow oil past turbo bearings, etc.
My mechanic once fogged the entire parking lot of his shop by blowing into a
hose hooked to a hole in an old oil cap on a 3rd gen - One of the race shops
told him about this, and he tried it because he didn't believe them.
From: Doug Underwood <dunderwood@underwoodair.com>
Subject: RE: (rx7) (all) NO 3 mm seals at (KD rotary and Hurley Apex seals )
There are only a few folks in this country w/ the proper jigging, etc. to
properly mill a set of rotors for 3mm apex seals. Due to problems w/ the
machine work from places known (by the tuners, anyway) for this work,
several have elected to drop 3mm seals. If the alignment isn't absolutely
true, the engine will leak oil like a sieve.
Mandeville no longer does 3mm seals, either. The machine shop they use has
not been able to hold tolerences on the machinework. One local car resulted
in a 4 way pissing match between the engine builder (who outsourced the
rotor milling), the installer, the turbo rebuilder, and the cars owner due
to oil consumption problems. After much gnashing of teeth, and many dollars
later, the culprit turned out to be improper machining for the seals.
The benefits of 2mm vs 3mm seals has been argued at length here before. The
biggest benefits of 3mm seals is being able to salvage a set of otherwise
trashed rotors.
But then, thats just my oppinion...
Doug Underwood
- -----Original Message-----
From: RICHARD HILL [mailto:twinturborx7r1@hotmail.com]
Sent: Wednesday, April 25, 2001 7:12 AM
To: Jrbjag@aol.com; rx7@world.std.com
Subject: (rx7) (all) NO 3 mm seals at (KD rotary and Hurley Apex seals)
This was taken from www.kdrotary.com/services/prices
"There are a lot of options when it comes to rebuilding your engine.. if you
have any questions please ask .. We want you to make an informed decision
and be happy with your RX-7.
NOTE: we no longer offer 3mm modifications.."
What gives ??
Richard
From: Tom Walsh <TWalsh@achieversusa.com>
Subject: RE: (rx7) (all) NO 3 mm seals at (KD rotary and Hurley Apex seals )
Since the subject of the true benefits of 3mm apex seals has come up again I
am reposting some information that I wrote up back in October of 2000 in
response to a question Wael had raised in regards to usage of 3mm seals in a
rebuild application.
[repost]
Wael you are correct about your assumption in regards to the 3mm seals being
used in lieu of new rotors. What happens is as the rotor rotates around
inside the engine the load points on the side of the apex seals shift from
one side to the other depending on its location in the motor. This "rocking"
of the seals cause not only wear on the sides of the apex seal but also on
the sides of the apex seal channel. As with any motor, wear occurs to both
components over time. The bottom and sides of the apex seals become worn (I
have a set of 3mm seals with 11,000 miles on them if you would like to see
what I am talking about) as well as to the top and bottom areas of the apex
seal channel on the rotor. So during a rebuild (if done professionally) the
tolerances of these apex channels are "mic'ed" (measured with a micrometer)
and are normally out of spec. So instead of throwing the rotors out and
buying new ones (I don't even know how much they cost new... I guess around
a $500 each?) the rebuilder will take the old rotors and send them off to a
machine shop and have the apex channels machined out to just under 3mm. They
then (if they are professionals) use gapping slivers and files to get the
clearances as near to perfect as possible. Often times they will leave it a
little on the thin side which will pinch the seals slightly, but due to the
wear of the metal on metal contact, the pieces should wear into "spec". For
this reason a break in period is crucial (change your oil OFTEN).
[ceramic info snipped]
One other area of concern is the corner seal (in 2 piece seals), and this is
more of an issue of the apex seal design in general rather than of size or
composition. The corner seal (which is a pain in the @ss during assembly) is
designed to spread the force of the spring laterally through the larger
section of the apex seal through the angled section of contact. What happens
is part of the spring force is also focused directly on the very narrow area
of contact that the corner section actually makes with the rotor housing.
This will often produce a corner seal "groove" on the rotor housing. (Just a
tip... If you are buying used rotor housings makes sure that you do not have
a corner seal "groove" on both sides of the rotor housing. It is often
common place for the rebuilders to take a rotor housing that was used once
and install the corner seal on the opposite side of the existing "groove" to
get more life out of the rotor housing. This is often a bad idea as the rest
of the apex seal can not make a proper seal on the other "grooved" side.
This will give you a raised section of your apex seal that will not seal
properly either. I have a picture of this too...)
So the corner section groove can be a problem with rotor housing wear... So
Hurley Engineering makes an enlarged corner section seal design. (I am
currently running a set in my car). This design is supposed to help spread
out the spring force over a larger area and help with rotor housing wear. My
car has 24K miles on the motor with these seals and I have not had a
problem. I am interested in seeing how the rotor housings fair but I will
wait until the motor tells me it is time. :-)
And if you have read down this far... I have a little tid bit for you...
When a ceramic seal shatters and imbeds itself into the rotor, no matter how
cool it looks or how tempted you might be to run your hand over it...
DON'T... You will bring back a bloody mess. :-)
And yes... 3mm seals will also imbed themselves into the face of a rotor too
(I have one of those too)...
I hope that helps... If you have any other questions please feel free to ask
away... I will try to answer them to the best of my knowledge.
[/repost]
Tom Walsh
'93 RED R1
I talked to Dave about this before he rebuilt my motor last
year. He said
that one of the reasons rebuilders use 3mm seals is because
often the slots
in the rotor for the apex seals become too worn to properly
accept a 2mm
seal. There is too much play and the seal would wobble.
Instead of replace
the rotor it is machined to accept a 3mm seal. Dave said that
the machining
had to be extremely precise and was very difficult to do
properly. If the
machining was off just the slightest amount, the seal would
be crooked and
could damage the motor. Supposedly the 3mm seals aren't any
stronger and
can't take more knock than the 2mm, unless we're talking
about upgraded
seals. Also, a 3mm seal is heavier and is more susceptible to
float at high
rpm. I don't know much about aftermarket seals, but have hear
that the ones
from Hurley are pretty good.
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org