Subject: Gearboxes vs Direct, was Engines & FAA
From: Paul
Date: 4/30/2001, 9:57 AM


Russell wrote> Fact: Every commercial passenger-carrying jet airplane flying
today is using not one,
but *several* gearboxes in the engines.  You don't see them falling out of
the sky
because of gearbox failures, do you?  What are the possible conclusions?

1. "LyCon GXX-YYY" drivers are not following proper engine management
techniques for
their geared engines (and presumably the ATPs are).
2. "LyCon GXX-YYY" gearboxes are not as well built as P&W or RR gearboxes.
3. "LyCon GXX-YYY" engines are not well suited to drive gearboxes, but P&W
and RR
engines are.

Mark wrote>
Most large turbofans just have one gearbox system, and they are pretty
simple with a crown and pinion driving a radial drive shaft from the high
pressure shaft, to a second angle gearbox, feeding the accessory gearbox
through a horizontal drive shaft being a pretty typical system. The
accessory gearbox itself is usually a simple straight cut gear train, with
power take off or the various accessories at various speeds.

Actually they are very reliable. As Paul pointed out there is no torsional
vibration from intermittant combustion to beat things to death. They run in
clean, cooled, combustion byproduct free oil, are designed with aid of
expensive FEA software by the manufactures centers of excellence,
manufactured with the FAA breathing down their necks, with an eye to ETOPS
shut down rates. Most accessories are driven off this gearbox with a shear
shaft to protect it from their failures. They are not exactly small or light
gears either, especially when you consider the relatively light loads most
accessories impart (the biggest on the GE90 are probably the 120KVa Main
Generator and the HMU). The accessory shaft is tapping a few hundred hp off
a  150,000+ hp high pressure shaft on the GE90.

1) When I was in the Air Force we had a flight of three Cessna 421's
(GTSIO-520 Conti's). Beautiful aircraft, but the pilots treated them like
jets. We got lousy TBO, and constant cylinder replacements, but I don't
remember many gearbox complaints (although the rest maybe didn't last long
enough for the gearbox to fail).

2) That the Lycon gearboxs aren't built as well as PW/GE/RR is probably true
because the amount of design, testing, and manufacturing  effort you can put
into a limited market $100K engine is probably less than that which is
affordable for a limited market $2-15 million engine. Not bad, just
relatively worse.

3) You have to pity a single spur gear set bolted between a twisting,
flexing, vibrating 6 throw crank shaft, and a flexing vibrating propellor,
as it is feed dirty combustion soiled oil.

One point on the Direct drive rotary, is it even feasible from a heat
rejection perspective to consider a 150hp+ air cooled rotary? Due to the
shape of these things, how could you possible fin the combustion chamber
area of a twin rotor big enough to produce this Hp at <3000 rpm? The
clearances would be a real problem to, as the hot side/cold side delta T
warps things.

Good point Mark. Jeff Spitzer gave up on air-cooling when he converted the
OMC air-cooled one rotor snow mobile engine to the two rotor
liquid cooled Moller or Freedom Motors engine.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org