Subject: large air cooled Wankel
From: Paul
Date: 4/30/2001, 10:28 PM


Obviously, it is possible to scale up a Wankel engine for relatively high
output
at lower output shaft rpm (ie 3000 or less). However, the Wankel is
demonstrably
a challenge for cooling, and as you scale any engine up, the heat paths
become

larger, and air cooling less practical. Even with virtual "micro milling" of
cooling fins,
the WWII radials ran out of size, and went to "corn cob" cylinder counts. I
really feel also, that the power to weight ratio would adversly suffer.
If you

halve the rpm at the same Brake Mean Effective Pressure, you have to double
the displacement. I think the big air cooled "direct" drive Wankel while
perhaps a good hope - is a faint one. - Vance



Vance might be right.   The max cylinder bore that was really practical with
high
BMEP piston engines was in the range of 5.5-6" .   Flame propogation speed was
a critical factor, but I bet cooling was an issue, too. They just added more
cylinders
and more supercharging after that.  Four-valve heads helped on the
water-coolers,
but don't work with aircooled heads - not enough room left for fins.  There
might be
a limit to rotor size as far as adequate cooling goes.

Similitude may be catching up with the design somewhere in this size range, but
I doubt it.  Surface area increases much more slowly than volume as we scale
up, so at some point cooling should become a problem.  This is why whales
are huge -
they need to stay warm in arctic seas, so they need a lot of heat source
(volume)
per heat loss (surface area).   We need the opposite, a favorable ratio of
surface
to volume.  For example, a one inch cube has a surface of 6 sq inches and a
volume
of 1 cubic inch.  Modest increases in the size of the cube have very
dramatic effect
on the surface to volume ratio.

                 cube size      surface area        volume
Area/volume ratio
                       1                  6                       1
6
                       2                24                       8
3
                       3                54                      27
2
                       4                96                      64
1.5
                       5              150                     125
1.2
                       6              216                     216
1.0

So, making heat on a volumetric basis and rejecting it on an areal basis is
a problem
at some point, no question.  The issue is "Can a 200hp @ 2800 RPM Wankel be
made
to cool properly with air cooling".   I'd bet yes, but can't prove it.

Jeff has run the calcs and built the engines.   I'd love to hear his take on
this.

Bill
Long EZ builder & pilot
BSME, MSME

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org