Subject: flying 700 nautical miles to cma
From: Paul
Date: 5/7/2001, 6:45 PM


Paul wrote:

Well guys you will never guess what it was. Had Perry and me going for days.

Cut for brevity .....

Perry and I came up with an emergency cooling system idea consisting of a aux coolant tank
with a couple of gallons of coolant and a high pressure pump (EFI fuel pump) to inject the
aux coolant into the pressurized engine cooling system.

There are several scenarios for a failed cooling system. this applies to any liquid cooled
aircraft engine and not just the rotary.


Paul ... and list ...

This has long been a goal of mine for an "ideal" water cooled system.  An "emergency only"
injection of water/glycol with a healthy dose of "World's Best Stop Leak" radiator sealer by
AlumAseal Corporation.   I put this stuff in the same category as JB weld  ... I don't
necessarily like it, but it works!   I have used this crud on more than one occasion on some
very substantial leaks, and it has always done the job.

You find yourself in a pretty untenable situation if you know you have a coolant leak, but can
do nothing about it ... especially if you find yourself half way to Hawaii.  At least with a
system such as I suggest, one has a chance of recovery ... if only to a reduced power setting,
due to decreased coolant levels.  You might be able to stay airborne, and not have to overheat
the engine.



A. Water pump failure. Little can be done in the air.


Agreed ... this part is as critical as a propellor, or the engine itself.  I believe you have
proven, by the numbers, that an electric backup is just not viable, and might perhaps just
pour more water/glycol out of the same leak


B. A leak in the system somewhere. Temporary transfer of coolant out of the aux coolant tank
will buy you some time to find a place to land.


With what I am proposing, (and your system) you just might be able to stop the leak, stay
airborne, and limp to land.


C. Combustion gases leaking into the coolant system. The plan for situation
B should help. Also route coolant from the overflow tank back into the engine
using the high pressure pump. Why pump it overboard to be lost forever.

Excellent idea!  Should be incorporated for sure!

Along the lines of an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure these are the things you
can and MUST do.

1. Number ONE!!!! Use AN line or wiggins couplings in the water system ONLY !!!!!. No hoses
and hose clamps!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Perry developed a leak in the cooling system at a hose
clamp joint.

Goes without saying, if you want a reliable system.

2. Pressure check the cooling system before starting the engine. Once the engine starts
there are too many variables to rely
on the cooling system pressure gage to give you a true story. At that point in time it is
too late to detect leaks. They may not show up right away. The coolant could be heating up
and expanding faster than it is leaking out maintaining the system pressure fooling you in
the process and making you think everything is OK.

Good point.  Is there any way you can think of to give you a "leak detection" warning device?
Short of an engine department video camera or a "sniffer".


Perry came up with the idea of using one of the heater outlets in the rear housing as a way
pre-flight pre-engine start pressurizing the coolant system with a small 12 volt electric
tire pump compressor available in any auto parts store. A tire tube schrader valve will
ensure it won't leak system pressure after you turn off the compressor.

Sounds like a viable pre flight item before my Hawaii leg!

See the picture below of a device I made to bolt in place of the stock Mazda  pressure cap
plastic fitting. This just
for trouble shooting. A method of doing this should be built into the system.

More about all this as we go along.

Paul Lamar

Dale Smith wrote:


Will be looking forward to this .... IMHO coolant leak has always been the water cooled
engine's "achilles heel", ... a critical failure problem, with no foreseeable fix.  What good
is the world's best water cooled engine ... with no water?

I think this thread is extremely important to the credibility of ANY water cooled engine, not
just the rotary.

Dale Smith

I totally agree. Anybody pushing water cooled aircraft engines are sooner or later
WILL need to address this issue.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org