Bulent Aliev wrote:
Yesterday an RV builder stopped by my hangar and told me that Ed
Anderson
has given up on the rotary and is installing Lycoming? Hope he was
kidding.
Bulent
Charlie Kuss wrote:
Buly,
I haven't heard anything from Ed about installing a Lycoming. I suspect
someone
is pulling your leg. I just got my new issue of the RVator (RV
newsletter) There
was a 3 page write up about Ed and his winning BEST AUTO ENGINE
CONVERSION at Sun
N' Fun. Who was it that told you this?
Charlie
We should hear from Ed any minute now unless he is on vacation :-)
Paul Lamar
Ed Anderson wrote:
Hi Charlie, Paul,
I suspect it must be an Lycoming company rep who is seriously concerned
about the revenue loss to all of us using the rotary and its impact on his
retirement plan {:>). As Charlie pointed out - a 3 page write up appeared
in the most recent issue of RVator on my installation. Per usual, I make
no pretense that problems did not exist and the article did contain several
of them. But, overall a very positive article pointing out the 9 flying RVs
and the web pages and e mail lists that now exists enabling hundreds of us
to exchange the good, the bad, and the ugly. Best of all it appeared in
RVator which gives it some credibility with many of the RV crowd. Also good
publicity for the rotary with the Sun & Fun award.
But, as I am certain you have all encountered, there are those who are
dogmatic about certified reciprocating engines regardless of the very high
prices and lack of technological advancement. I think some of that comes
from the fact that we are getting reliable installations for under $10,000
and they are getting frequently unreliable installations for over $20,000.
They seem able to ignore the numerous problems with Lycomings (not to
mention the expense). Apparently if you go down with a failed, expensive,
out of date, Lycoming it is somehow honorable. But if you go down with an
auto engine then it is because of your stupidity. Personally, I figure
that I would rather avoid the high price of a Lycoming engine failure when I
could have one that would be a lot cheaper with a rotary (if it should
fail). The thing I have observed is that when a rotary engine installation
has problems it is almost always associated with the auxiliary systems
rather than the basic engine. On the other hand, many certified aircraft
engine failures are with the basic engine rather than the auxiliary systems.
Does this begin to suggest something? Hummmm.
In any case, still Hummmming along flying to local fly-ins and continuing to
be requested to take off the cowl so folks can see the installation.
Best Regards
Ed Anderson
I am fed up with my C182. My wife won't let me sell it because she says
"What are we going to fly while you are working on the Kis Cruiser?" Latest
is the FAA has rejected the first draft on my one time STC to put
in a factory reman 2000 hour TBO version of the Cont. O-470 instead of
the 1500 hour TBO version. You would think the FAA would encourage that.
I am looking at a bill for about $25,000 so far and I am still not done
and ready to fly. It has cost me far more than the extra 500 hours
theoretical engine life warrants. It is just plain economic masochism
and stupidity to own a certified aircraft or a certified aircraft engine.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org