Subject: Greg's Ross Aero Rant
From: ACRE NL
Date: 6/1/2001, 6:13 AM

Greg Richter wrote:

I didn't think there was anyone still contemplating using the Ross
redrive.  Please don't.  Here's my 2 cents on why:

I bought a 2.17 redrive from Lou Ross quite a long time ago.  By the time I
got around to getting ready to use it, and looked closely, I decided not to
fly it.  It's not, IMHO, airworthy.

We used the Ross drive for engine testing on the ground while the shop made
something more realistic to fly with.  The Ross Bull-Sheisse lasted
_almost_ to the 4 hour mark before the bearings started to go West.

Teardown showed a thrust bearing under more stress than a .com CEO, with a
lot more movement than I'd like to see in the planet carrier and unhappy,
oil starved bearings hinting about going on strike shortly.  The prop-side
oil seal puffed and started to leak right on cue, so, we took it apart to
see WTF was happening in there.  It might be instructive, right?

It took a  torch, press and some patience to get the blasted thing apart
...   A cursory inspection determined the best course of action: we buried
the parts in an unmarked dumpster.  I didn't see the weld slag on the
inside until then -- they didn't even clean the %%#%$ parts before assembly!

Lou was reputed to be a good machinist, although not trained as an engineer
to my knowledge.
Chris, his son, seems pleasant enough on the phone, but is non-responsive
for whatever reason and isn't really available anymore.  No sense bashing
the guy.  He just isn't in this business -- his father was, he isn't.

The redrive as designed is defective, due to the gross misapplication of
ball bearings where there should have been rollers, the way they attempt to
handle lubrication and the way the planet carrier is implemented.  Top this
with a bit of sloppy machine work and substandard welding and you've got
bad news by the carload.  Tracy Crook has been through some similar level
of Ross annoyance, as indicated on his Website, but I can't speak of his
experience directly.

Take the above as what it is -- one builder's experience and one engineer's
opinion.  I may be a little neurotic about engines and such things, but I
know junk when I see it too.  ;)

Cozy N722 -- Mazda 13B
Turbo  http://bluemtn.com/greg  -or-  http://bluemountainavionics.com

The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org