Paul,
I feel that most builders are undersizing their oil cooler inlet. For
180 HP we seem to agree that a total cooling inlet area of 60 sq in to
80 sq in is needed and that 1/3 of this should be for the oil cooler;
this is suggested by both Fred Morino's engineering analysis and also
Ed Anderson's flying RV-6. That means that the oil cooler inlet would
need to be somewhere between 20 sq in and 26.5 sq in. That would be a
5" to 6" round inlet. I believe that Ed is now running an oil cooler
inlet of ~ 25 sq in and 2 radiator inlets of 25 sq in (correct me if I
am wrong there, Ed). These numbers have been proven both with a
flying airplane and theoretically (Fred's engineering analysis).
Area for Round inlets: (3" & 4" are not nearly enough)
3" = 7.07 sq in
4" = 12.56 sq in
5" = 19.63 sq in
5.5" = 23.75 sq in
6" = 28.27 sq in
Didn't we decide some months ago that an oversize cooling inlet
probably wasn't really such a large drag producer? Seems like
external diffussion would minimize the effects of being slightly too
large?
Ken Powell
Ed Anderson wrote:
Ken, you are correct on my inlet sizes. I feel that anything much below
20-25 sq inch opening for the 0il cooler is on the too small size. I tried
a 3", 4" and even a 5" duct at one time. The 5" was OK until the OAT got
above 85-90F then the oil temps started pushing my redline (220F). However,
to be fair, when I was using the 5" duct I was using a 8x11x1" EARL oil
cooler near the firewall and while I built a large plenum to diffuse the air
it just would not do the job on those hot days.
I agree with Paul, that IF you get the inlets and outlets optimized that
smaller areas would probably work OK, but most of us are probably safer with
a little larger opening. Lets face it, if your oil temps are too high, then
you certainly won't be able to keep it at high power setting and so a bit
more drag is sort of a moot point if not enough cooling. Also, Jim Mosur
(who I borrowed the idea from) showed that his 3"x10" opening dropped oil
temps 40F. So I replaced the EARL cooler with a stock Mazda and moved it up
under the spinner. Vola! my oil temps problems went away.
Ed Anderson
"when I was using the 5" duct I was using a 8x11x1" EARL oil
cooler near the firewall and while I built a large plenum to diffuse the air
it just would not do the job on those hot days.
5 inches diameter or 20 square inches of opening is 22% of 8 x 11
almost the exact rule of thumb for a rad opening.
I always thought Ed gave up too soon on that set up :-) It had a real nice
snorkel intake design after he eliminated the NACA duct. I was hoping he
would move the cooler away from the firewall to free up the outflow air
and improve the transition from round 5 inch rubber ducting to the 8x11x1
flat oil cooler with a bell shaped duct. We were making progress Ed and
you used a sledge hammer :-)
Perhaps my expectations are too high. Perhaps we need to learn to walk before
we can run. First order of business is get it to cool. Use the sledge hammer
if necessary :-) After just about everybody can do that then we can start
to worry about drag. IMHO that prize money for the fastest rotary over 200 mph
is going to stay in the bank for awhile and collect interest :-)
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org