Subject: Oil water heat xchanges and LS-1 coils
From: ACRE NL
Date: 6/21/2001, 2:49 PM


marc wiese wrote:

I also recall that Tracy Crook tried to emulate the early 2nd gen
OEM
oil-water cooler (even the car people decry them and update to the
later
air cooler) and that it did not work for him, so he added copper
pipe to
the oil pan as well (read his book). I think he now has all oil to
air
coolers. Right?

Mike Wills wrote:

  That doesnt mean the concept is wrong, just that the execution of the
concept was poor. The factory oil-water cooler clearly didnt have
sufficient capacity.

  A low buck approach to an oil-water cooler might be to pick up several
of
those Mazda coolers in the scrap yard and run them in parallel. I agree,
there is no free lunch and in doing this you would have to increase
radiator capacity.

  As I recall Tracy tried the factory oil-water cooler in place of the
air-oil cooler. When that didnt work he went back to the air-oil cooler
and
then added that oil pan coolant loop. I've often wondered why he didnt
supplement the air-oil cooler by running it in series with the oil-water
cooler to get the additional oil cooling that he needed rather than
running
that loop in the pan? That oil pan loop always struck me as a poor
approach. Since the oil in the pan has very little flow across the
coolant
loop (compared to a conventional oil-water cooler plumbed in a high flow
line) it seems that it would be relatively inefficient in transferring
heat. And the idea of punching big holes in the oil pan and brazing in
copper pipe seems pretty scary from a failure mode standpoint. Correct
me
if I'm wrong on this Tracy, and if not why didnt you try this?

Mike Wills


Your logic is correct Mike but I am dead serious when it comes to weight.
Adding an oil cooler (of either type) adds weight so I was looking for a
single cooler that would do the job.  BTW, that little Mazda oil-water
cooler weighs as much as the oil-air version.

 After I got my air ducts working better I eventually removed the oil pan
heat exchanger just to save the 1 1/2 pounds of plumbing.  My cooling is
still not perfect but the only limitation is at maximum climb on a 90+ F
day.  This means I have to settle for 1000 fpm instead of 2300.  Not a real
operational limitation unless I was doing time to climb competition.

Todays project --- replacing my heavy Mazda trailing coil/igniters with AC
Delco LS-1 coil/igniters.  Saves a whopping 4 pounds.

Tracy Crook
tcrook@rotaryaviation.com
www.rotaryaviation.com

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org