Subject: Database/CAD/CNC/INFO/etc - Organizing the community.
From: ACRE NL
Date: 6/30/2001, 7:38 AM


<< Wrathall Mark wrote:

Rich, I think some of your ideas have merit, which is why I started the best
 > practices site. However, there are only around 20-30 fixed wing 13b powered
 > aircraft which have flown (my estimate) and all have had configuration
 > diffences. This is inherent in homebuilding, everyone has different
 > priorities.

Yes, Mark, everyone has different priorities with the kind of plane their
building, but the basic core problems
with the engine should be the same for all, Exhaust manifold, Fuel Injection,
Apex Seals, O-rings, Turbos, etc.
The goal for ALL, I would think, is to build the most compact, lightest, MAX
HP, bullet proof engine here.
Were talking about manily two engines here in this group, the 13B, and the
20B. Most people are probably
using the 13B account of it's availability.There will be differences with
Props, PSRU's, mufflers, turbo versus
non-turbo. How many different kinds of planes are we talking about here, with
only 20-30 actually flying with
the 13B as you say? We could still have a central database of info that
covers everyones needs.

While a single standardized RV-4 installation for example, would
 > be of value for many, those pioneers like who have already done it probably
 > wouldn't have paid the extra money to gain that value. If someone doesn't
 > want to get involved in the engineering , Powersport is working hard to
 > deliver a good product tailored to them. For those who only want to avoid
 > the hard jobs, there is an increasing number of vendors in the community
 > offering component solutions (Tracy springs to mind). Remember those most
 > able to nail down standard firewall forward configurations have commercial
 > interests to protect.

I think I read in another post here that this option was someting like
$20,000. That kind of option is the reason why,
a lot of us are here in the first place, cost, and $200+ for a $15 valve.
Now, I don't know, what they are giving you for that
kind of price, do you have a web address for them, I would like to read up on
it. The engine must be Gold plated or
someting for a $4000 engine from Mazda.

 > Whether you cut up the stock intake, weld up steel tube bends, beat and
weld
 > aluminuim runners, cast a manifold,  layup a composite manifold, or trade
 > dollars for time and buy a standard intake from some one else is going to
be
 > a function of your personality and skills. In the end, it really doesn't
 > matter, as long as the installation is safe, and follows sound engineering
 > principles.


As long as we continue to follow that trail, I'm afraid we as a group will
never see the rotary in many airplanes for many many years. In the 5+
years Tracy has been doing his testing, we still, only have 20-30 others
flying/testing as you say, out of the thousands and thousands of
small commerical/kit planes out there. Question, does Lycoming build a
different 0320 for every aircraft? No, I don't think so. They made up
design teams, fuel injection, heads, blocks, rods, pistons, etc., and built
the best product they could. When new technolgy comes along they
make improvements to the design. We need to focus more as a team of a 1000
minds, not 20-30 minds. Some here, have commercial interests
to protect, but most of us don't. We just want to build the most compact,
lightest, MAX HP, bullet proof engine, so we can fly our plane soon.


 > This is why Bill, Paul and many others keep coming back to AC43-13 and
write
 > essays on bearings etc. This is also one of the principles I am trying to
 > capture on the best practices site.

Yes, we need to be thankful to all that share their knowledge with all of us.
Thank You, Guys/Gals

 > The second aspect of the best practises site, is to collect and catalog
 > known failure modes and how to avoid them. This applies to both the core
 > engine and commonly used components.

Yes, this is very important.

 > You are correct that that site has a long way to go, and I welcome content
 > from the community.

I will pass anything I find of value, along to you for your site. My main
interest, is getting all the info to people interested
in rotarys/planes available 24/7.

 > Those who have been on the newsgroup for a couple of years or longer, see
 > that there is a cycle of topics, with a honeing of the knowledge each time
 > they come back up. This works well, as often we have someone who has flown
 > the ideas from the last cycle and gives us hard data feed back. Some
 > conclusion from last year have been proven incorrect. Databasing all
 > information tends to weight it all equally, whereas in practice many of the
 > older drawings are of little value.
 > Mark Wrathall

Yes, I agree, we learn more as time goes by, that is why we have drawing,
alternatorbracket0001, alternatorbracket0002, alternatorbracket0003, etc.
What about the things that have been solved already for the newbys/old timers
here, example-exhaust/intake flange plate, E shaft oil block off, etc.?
Where is the drawings? That's why we need a database site. So we all aren't
redoing everything over and over. Yes, you can still improve on them designs
with your idea's, alternatorbracket0001A, alternatorbracket0002B,
alternatorbracket0003C, etc., and upload them to the database for all to look
at/use.
You know there are hundreds of things that were designed many many years ago
that were lost, because they weren't documented, they ran out of money, died,
just lost interest, etc., and then some one today has the same idea,
discovers a drawing, and proceeds with the project, and we call it a new
product.

 It is true I have taken a lot of drawings off the web site and replaced them
 with newer drawings.
  >>

Mark, with 80+ Gig Hard Drives today cheap, you could leave them on an
ftp/web site for all to see. It may spark a new idea from and old idea.
Rich Gillen

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org