Jerry Hey wrote:
Paul (and Bill Freeman) I hate to write this because it really reveals
my ignorance (but who was I kidding anyway). According to the Bingelis
books the height of a NACA opening is related to its width: an aspect
ratio of 3-5 (width divided by height).
I read that as: "an aspect ratio between 3:1 and 5:1 (width:height)."
The example given shows a 3" wide opening and a 3/4" height. I have
worked the simple arithmetic every way I can think and cannot come out
with this result.
3 / 0.75 = 4 [read as 4:1]
I also graphed his example and came out with different values than
shown: a 3/4" height with a 7º ramp is not 6.75" in length but 6.17".
That problem is: at 7 deg., what is the X when Y=0.75? Remembering our
trigonometry, we come up with:
X = Y / sin(7)
X = 0.75 / 0.121869343
X = 6.154131786
This is really 6" if one follows significant digits. For example, if
instead of 7.00000 deg the ramp is 7.49 deg, then X would be 5.75". Can
you control your ramp angle down to 0.5 deg increments?
Alternately, if the X is fixed at 6.75", then what is the ramp angle?
Trigonometry again:
R = arctan(Y/X)
R = arctan(0.75/6.75)
R = arctan(0.1111111)
R = 6.34 deg
Perhaps the "ramp height" (above) is the NACA opening, and the total height
includes the thickness of the upper lip? To get a ramp length of 6.75, the
total height must be:
Y = X / sin(7)
Y = 6.75 * 0.121869343
Y = 0.822618068 [ about 13/16" ]
So if the opening is 3/4", then the upper lip thickness must be 1/16".
This seems rather optimistically thin. :-)
I don't have the Bingelis book, so I don't know why your numbers don't
match, unless it's just slop.
My question is twofold: what is the height of a 10" (and 12") wide NACA
duct opening? And how did you derive it? ( RE: Page 187 The
SportPlane Builder) and page 198,199 of Sport Plane Construction
Techniques). I already accept that it is I who am screwed up and not
Tony who was one of my gods.
Ratio:
3:1 4:1 5:1
Width:-----------------------------
10" 3 5/16" 2 1/2" 2"
11" 3 11/16" 2 3/4" 2 3/16"
12" 4" 3" 2 3/8"
Paul Lamar responded:
I don't have either one of those books Jerry.
If it is 3:1 it is 4 inches deep if it is 5:1 it is 2.4 inches deep based
on a 12 inch wide duct.
That still will not give you enough inlet area. The duct must be 18
inches wide and about 6 inches deep for about 108 square inches inlet
area.
Where do you get this from, Paul? Using our 1:4 inlet:radiator rule of
thumb, that opening is appropriate for a radiator with 432 sq. in.
(18"x24", or 19"x22.75", or ...). Isn't that a bit large? Or does the 1:4
ratio only apply to forward-facing cowl openings and not NACA ducts?
Russell Kent
I just threw in a little because it don't work as well as forward
facing perpendicular openings. Plus Jerry has that huge 800 cubic inch
radiator. If the opening is too small he is carrying around all that extra
weight for no good reason.
I don't know about you Russell but the best I can do in composites
is +/- 1/8 inch and +/- 2 degrees :-)
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org