> >I just threw in a little because it don't work as well as forward
>facing perpendicular openings. Plus Jerry has that huge 800 cubic inch
>radiator. If the opening is too small he is carrying around all that extra
>weight for no good reason.
>
>I don't know about you Russell but the best I can do in composites
>is +/- 1/8 inch and +/- 2 degrees :-)
>
>Paul Lamar
As far as controlling ramp angle is concerned, if I use a parallel
sided ramp built of sheet metal, the result will be very accurate.
That is why I am interested in data that seems to indicate that at
the speeds I will be flying (below 500 mph), parallel and divergent
(NACA) ducts are equivalent.
Also, I wonder at phrase "all that weight for no good reason" in
describing a radiator that is at the most 100 cubes larger than a
bare minimum (at least by my standards). That is a 5" x 10" x 2"
chunk of radiator core. What do you think it weighs? I think not
more than a few ounces. The "good reason" is that cooling is a bit
of a witches art that is not that predictable. A little extra
radiator is insurance. One thing I am not clear on is whether or
not I can derive some benefit from a larger rad assuming the air is
not increased proportionally. In other words, given the same inlets
and outlets would a larger radiator outperform a smaller one? If I
knew exactly how much air was passing through the rad, then I could
do with a minimum core size. The best engineer on this list could
not hope to predict exact air flow. Too many variables. A little
larger rad, a little more weight, and a better chance at success--
that is what I am thinking. What is not so easy to swallow is the
possibility that I will have to install a fan for ground ops. The
one supplied by Griffin with bracket is 3 lbs. Whether or not I will
need this is not predictable. I will have to wait and see. The fan
is rated at 1300 cfm.
The 1:4 inlet rule is impossible to achieve in most airplanes and
those RVs with stock cowlings that are cooling successfully don't
come close. The RV cowl openings are 3" x 7". That is a total of 42
sq. in!!! Less than half of what the 1:4 rule seems to require.
Looks like that rule is ignoring the facts. One thing I am certain
of is that 100 cu in inlets and 130 cu in outlets will result in
draggy , slow, ugly airplanes.----Jerry
Its the antifreeze at 8 or 9 pounds per gallon.
One gallon is 232 cubic inches.
That is the why the car rule is given in such terms as 1/4.
Sloppy tolerance +/- 1/8 :-)
The car could climb a hill at 50 mph towing a trailer in 110
degree F weather. My Dodge Caravan overheats consistently up
at 4000 feet going up a 4% to 5% grade at 60 MPH with no trailer.
Big and powerful $90 electric fan and all. That is less than
say 60 HP continuos. That is also about 300 feet per minute.
With a load of around 3300 pounds that is 30 HP for
lifting that weight, that fast, alone not counting
aero and rolling drag at 60 MPH. Give it another 30 HP.
You on the other hand are going to want to climb
at 1500 to 2000 feet per minute at a gross weight of
1500 to 2000 pounds for a HP requirement of roughly
90 HP not including aero drag. Say 150 HP total. True
the dynamic pressure available to cool is four times
as much at 120 MPH. But our experiences for
the past three years has not been good. I am not entirely
sure why but I think the guys are not paying enough attention
to cowling back pressure on the rads.
You cannot see air flow so it is very hard to visualize what
is going on without taking a bunch of pressure measurements.
Don't forget, the 3 X 7 inlets the guys are using are in an ideal
perpendicular place while yours are in a horizontal area parallel
to the slip stream in the boundary layer. Further more those people
will also admit that they climb out 130 MPH to improve
the cooling which is probably less than best angle.
Most of them don't have to climb over 10,000 foot mountains
>from 245 feet ASL like I do at SZP.
The other thing they got going for them is the prop
blast during ground ops which you will not benefit much from.
I just want to see yours cool right off the bat. Too many
people have been discouraged and have given up when they were
unable to get the Mazda to cool. Worse they ruin the engine.
You do that once or twice and you say: "Hey! Why am I messing with
a water cooled airplane?" Plan on the fan.
Paul
Before I respond it is time to thank you and others who are willing
to think and communicate about these issues. Participating here is
challenging, fun and educational. My entire cooling system has been
designed in the notes that have been passed back and forth.
I don't think the tubes in the little (100 cu in) core section have
enough volume to make much difference in coolant weight. However, I
am going to find out. I will fill my little rad and then subtract
the tank volume. Let you know.
My proposed inlets are in a high pressure area and will receive
significant prop blast.
No where near as high as the perpendicular front of the cowl.
IMHO you are fooling yourself Jerry. You can prove it with
the mock up in a pickup truck bed trick.
Further, the cowl flaps are also in the prop
blast. Prop blast is very hard along the bottom of a Tailwind. If
you ever run one up on a gravel runway, you will be appalled by the
damage to the belly paint. I really do believe that the system
will "draw" even at low rpm. How low is the question. Five
minutes after the engine is fired for the first time, I will know if
I need a fan or not. Incidentally the fan offered by Griffin is
rated at 1300 cfm. How does this stack up against 13-b cooling
requirements at low and high rpm?
Large submerged inlets do not bother me at all. They are clean and
hidden as opposed to "ugly holes" in the face of the cowling.
Likewise with cowl doors under the stab.
Worse case scenarios might be that a scoop would have to be added to
the inlets or the fan would have to be run all or most of the time. I
don't believe either of these will be required, but I do acknowledge
the possibility. It is an experimental. I think the design phase
has about run its course. Time to go to work. Jerry
There is a significant weight of coolant in the feed pipes.
Don't go small on those as the water pump will have a time of
it anyway. I would say about 1.25 ID minimum.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org