Subject: advantage of water cooling ?
From: ACRE NL
Date: 7/5/2001, 8:18 AM


I built an RV-4 with an O-320 Lyc.

I cut the cowling intake openings down to 2" x 6" with rounded
corners +/-
17" per side for a total of 34 SQ. IN. and never had any kind of
cooling
problem.

Hank

Its that 300 degree F temperature difference will help
you every time. I'll also bet you did a good job on sealing the
baffles.

Paul Lamar

Finn Lassen wrote:

So what's the advantage of water cooling (apart from shock cooling)?

Finn

The wankel rotary engine.

Paul Lamar


True, but it goes a bit further than that.  The apparent advantage of air
cooling is not as much as the higher differential would suggest.  The much
smaller area for heat dissipation on aircooled requires a very turbulent
airflow so the actual volume of cooling air required can be greater than for
a watercooled engine.   The temperature of the exiting air of the system is
the actual indicator of effeciency.

Tracy Crook
tcrook@rotaryaviation.com
www.rotaryaviation.com

I think this is at the heart of the water cooling problem right
here. Note that the rate of temperature drop off in the interface
between the metal and the coolant is very high. In other words the 
metal itself is a better conductor of heat than the interface
between metal and liquid coolant.

This means that more heat stays in the metal adjacent to the 
combustion chamber. On the other hand, in an air cooled engine, 
the cooling fins remain much much hotter on out to their ends 
enhancing the heat transfer to the ultimately cooling fluid. 
The surrounding ambient air itself! 

The final rate of heat transfer between
the combustion chamber metal and ambient air  of course being a very 
strong function of the temperature difference.

There are other very complicated issues like getting enough
air cooling fins in the right places. This is why the rotary 
is better with liquid cooling as it is near impossible to air cool
the end housings in a multiple rotor wankel. It makes a more 
compact package with a shorter e-shaft.

The very bottom line is the limit of the melting temperature of the
metal adjacent to the combustion chamber. This is why we
need CHT gauges in the rotary.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org

heat-trans-cyl-wall-d.gif

housing-temp-vs-h2o-temp.gif