I got it this time Jerry. Some essential suggested changes in red.
50 square inches is not enough. Particularly if you are going
to tap off induction air. More like 100 square inches is
called for. A duct 5 by 19 would be more like it.
I am sorry but you cannot get a quart in a pint pot.
On the other hand if you flew your airplane upside down
on the back of a pickup truck and you proved to me
you had at least 20 pounds per square foot or .144 PSI
or two inches of water on the face of a rad
at 100 MPH I would sign off on a smaller duct :-)
Paul Lamar
Jerry Hey wrote:
I think the formula you are using is flawed simply because every
flying example I have seen is using far smaller inlets. This
includes all the RVs at Sun-N-Fun if they are using the stock cowls.
I don't know what Chuck's inlet size is but in the pic I saw it
seemed much smaller than what you are prescribing.
How do you explain Tracy's, Finn's Ed's and Chucks cooling success?
If I am wrong about these airplanes, explain to me where I am wrong.
Chuck Dunlop's rad is, I think, 540 cu in. One forth of that is 135
sq in. There is no way, he can fit that much intake on his cowl and
still have something that looks good and flies cleanly. If we
really have to achieve the inlet sizes you recommend , then the water
cooled engine is never going to work out for small, light aircraft
because they simply don't have the space for adequate inlets and even
larger outlets. I am sure most of the guys on this list want their
final projects to look every bit as good as the conventional powered
airplanes on the Ramp. I know this is important to me. Too much
labor, energy, time and money to settle for an ugly duckling.
However, my impression is just the opposite. Slick airplanes with
rotarys purring under the cowls are already in the air. On these
airplanes the average intakes seem to be less that 50 sq. in. (42 Sq
in for the RVs) I think we should figure out how they are doing it
and make intelligent use of the information to move ahead. Huge
inlets seem to be a step backwards.
If my inlets are as large as Tracy's and I provide good ducting and
adequate outlet, then I expect to have no cooling problems.
Granted, my submerged inlet proposal needs to be proven, but a 50 sq
in inlet on the nose of the cowl, perpendicular to the air stream, in
the prop wash, has already been shown to work.
Shoot me down with real life examples, Jerry
Jerry
Are they successful? Tracy Crook will tell you he does not climb
out at max angle. Also Tracy does not use the stock RV openings.
Chuck will tell you the same thing when the temp gets
over 90 degrees F and he thinks he is still down on power.
Until someone climbs at at max angle on a 100 degree day
with 185 HP or more I will stick by my formula.
I will also modify the formula when I receive info from
the guys indicating their cowl pressure is near zero
relative to static pressure and their airplanes meet
the above criteria.
In addition they are not feeding air through a six foot long duct.
I am just trying to save you a bunch of heartache Jerry.
What are you going to do if your 50 square inch duct does not
cool?
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org