Wrathall Mark wrote:
Paul wrote>This plate does double duty. As such it is a weight
saver even if it is not pocketed out on an NC mill. Those center
housing mounts would be heavy. Also it would be tough to get the
mounts on the center housing and still get the turbo on there with
out building something heavy down low well under the turbo.
this scheme also gives room for an under the cowl muffler.
Mark wrote> It is clear that this is the best solution for your aircraft. As
I have plans for the RV-4, the width of this is a non starter. It is for a
normally asperated RV-4 (or other narrow/tall installation) that my
thoughts lead. Given the weight of the ears on your Mount plate and the
extra length of the mount tubes, a mount to your design, picking up center
housing mounts should be no heavier.
Looking at this picture, I see this is exactly what Mike has done, except
the top mounts are then probably overkill. The Exhaust side mount will have
a tougher time with heat than where you put it.
Mark Wrathall
Lets put some numbers on it Mark. As I recall the plate is just
four pounds heavier than Tracy's plate at 15 pounds and the tubes
are eight inches longer. The tubes are 3/4 inch by .049 wall so
they weigh .0346 pounds per inch. Times eight inches and times 6 tubes
or 1.66 pound. So the incremental weight is 5.66 pounds.
With pocketing we can get that down to 3.66 pounds.
Depending on how well you design the center housing rubber
bushing brackets it could be a wash.
There is no doubt that if you use two tripods to the center
housing the loads on the rear mount will still be low providing
the bushings are placed close enough to the thrust lines.
The lower the bushings the more rear mount up load you get
from the counter clockwise moment due to thrust. Furthermore
the CG of the engine/psru/prop is now ahead of the rubber
mounts adding to the counter clockwise moment looking at it
from the left side.
With Mike Wills low bushing mounts the loads on the
upper rear mounts are considerable. Also with two widely spaced rubber
bushings on the rear mount the rear mount is called on to resist
some of the torque from the engine. Therefore Mike's rear mount tubes
as shown here need vertical supports at the rubber bushing ends.
He would be better off with one rubber bushing back there.
In this picture of Mike Wills mount taken from the right side of
the engine the thrust and weight moment is clockwise.
The Power sport rear/top mount shown in the second picture is a much
better way to do it but it adds height to the engine and is a bit
heavy.
This sounds like sour grapes but be my guest and run the numbers
yourself :-)
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org