<snip>
I still say that the Bonanza moved around in flight because of the flat
surface
of the rear fuselage. It wasn't enough movement to be a wallow though.
Tip
tanks and the Skeg dampened it to almost nothing.
Roger Robertson
Monty Roberts wrote:
One of my former flight instructors who was also a chopper pilot described a
problem with the early model of the small Huges chopper (Magnum PI type
chopper) had due to a v tail configuration. It would wallow around in cruise
and was appearantly very anoying. Eventually they solved the problem by
placing a conventional T tail on the back of the tail boom. He had personal
experience flying both the early and later models of the aircraft. The T
tail is what all of the current models of this helicopter use. I personaly
like V tails, but this is another data point which suggestst that they do
tend to wallow around in cruise. Perhaps like many things this is a problem
only if designed improperly, or used in the wrong circumstance. I'm no
aerodynamicist so I will reserve judgement for those more qualified.
Monty
Bill Freeman wrote:
A V tail cross couples the yaw and pitch axes. Any upset in pitch will lead to
some yaw response. The "skeg" was a U channel in the bottom of the the
V-tail "Bonana" that added a pure yaw stiffness which apparently helped
reduce the hunting in yaw. Also, an inverted Vtail is the "correct" design
due to
the positive yaw-roll coupling. An upright Vtail has negative yaw-roll
coupling,
leading to more adverse yaw, where the inverted V naturally cancels some
of the adverse yaw. Check with Jeff on why the Predator has an inverted
V - I'm sure he'll verify this is part of the reason, altho prop protection
in an
over-rotation is probably another part of the reason.
Bill Freeman
Translation. In a typical tail when you put in some left rudder it causes
a torque around the fuselage longitudinal axis tending to roll
the airplane clockwise and counter to what is called for to turn
left. Namely a roll counter clockwise. At the same time it also
yaws the airplane left which speeds up the right wing and slows
the left wing which tends to rotate the fuselage clockwise and
tries to turn the aircraft left. The net effect is a pure yaw
more or less.
I will leave all the other combinations and permutations for you to
work out for both a V tail and an inverted V tail :-)
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org