Subject: Ross PSRU - bad!! lubricants??
From: ACRE NL
Date: 8/8/2001, 11:59 AM


Don Dunbar wrote:

The oil temperatures that the PRSUs run with engine lubrication worry me
as
it is my experience that gears fail if run at 100c and above. Most gear
manufacturers like to have more like 60c. We have run gear boxes at 100c
and
above with consistent failures. The manufacturer told use this was
common
and we should not be concerned that this was the cause of the failures.
We
decided to install a heat exchanger on these units our self. After the
modification we had no more failures.

Before the heat exchanger was added we tried many types of oil to
resolve
the problems, syntectics and many high temp oils.The manufacturer of
this
gearbox has now added a heat exchanger. At the high temperatures oil
seals
and high speed input shaft where a common. the high speed shaft only run
at
2300 rpm not 6500 rpm. We are also use engine oil in these boxes that
has
engine contamination. I would like not use the engine lube system.
Regards Don


I am with you Don. I think it would be great if your box had a separate
oil supply.

Paul Lamar


I have often wondered about the gearbox lube situation. In the original
application the gears run in Dextron/Mercon type auto trans fluid (I
believe). The older Ford C-6 and C-4 used regular red ATF. I assume (maybe
wrongly) that  the fluid is selected mostly for the hydraulics and clutches
in the trans, and not for the gear train. What little I know about gear
design makes me think that the gears are designed to live with the less than
ideal ATF. I would think that a high pressure gear lube would be more
suitable. The only problem is that the viscosity of high pressure lube is
usually relatively high. If the clearances on the gears are designed for a
low viscosity ATF and you try to use the higher viscosity gear oil, I think
you will have a very hot gearbox on your hands. So what to do? I see nothing
wrong with using a good multigrade lube oil here (20W50). This would give
you some of the qualities of both types of lubricant, and it should be
superior to the ATF in terms of gear lube. The temp of the oil exiting the
box will probably be higher than a single grade lower viscosity lube (30W),
but the gears will be better protected. As far as the engine contaminating
the gearbox goes, if you are using filtered oil from the oil cooler it is
probably better than what most gearboxes see in service (sealed, no filter,
no cooler). If the engine fails, the gearbox is irrelevant. I am more
worried about the gearbox beginning to fail in a non catastrophic manner and
causing a problem with the engine.

Addressing the issue of contamination of the engine with metal from the
gearbox. Is there a bypass valve in the filter? How do the chips get into
the main oiling system. I can see how they could fail the oil pump. I agree
with Bill Freeman that a chip detector and magnetic drain plug are a
necessity. Also check your filter by cutting it open at oil changes.

Also if I remember correctly the temps seen in an automatic trans are higher
than 200 deg F. I don't think that it is correct to make a blanket statement
that all gearboxes will fail if run over 100C. There are too many variables.
The metal is certainly not going to break down at this temp. I would think
that the lube and load factors would matter more. I'm not saying that the
temperature was not the cause in the instance cited, just that it is
probably not universally applicable.

Does anybody know what the viscosity of ATF is? Has anybody measured the
temp of the oil exiting the gearbox with different viscosity oils?

I think that the late model Jeep full time transfer case has a pump in it
that might work if you wanted to use a separate sump, and trans fluid. This
adds a lot of extra complexity and weight, especially if you need another
oil cooler.

Monty

Did you get the oil schematic I just uploaded Mountie?

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org