Steve Gagnon wrote:
This is my first post with you gentlemen, so, I hope you will excuse any
irreverence. I have been monitoring this site for a few weeks since I'm
considering to build a RV-7 and use the Rotary Power that you've got running
so well. I am a mechanical eng. By trade with a little experience in the
hydraulic oil field. Specifically with the hydraulic machines used in the
plastic injection molding business. My work has lead me to some conclusions
about oils that may be helpful. Post this if you want, I won't be offended.
The oil that these Ford gears normally see and were designed for is
Automatic Transmission Fluid. They seem to be subjected to the same/similar
loads in that environment and seem to be surviving in that automotive world
just fine. Especially in the truck end of the business. (I think that
Tracey Cook has discovered the secret to this by going to the 6 gear unit to
distribute the loads.)This environment does require the use of an oil cooler
because the additive package used in the oil protects it from heat and
moisture, in any form.
ATF is basically a 30 weight hydraulic oil with a red dye added to it. The
red color came about because the first automatic transmissions that came on
the scene were notorious for having leaks. The red dye made it easier for
the mechanics to see where the leaks were.
It is my understanding that the automotive industry uses ATF primarily to
keep the automatic transmission, which is a hydraulically controlled
machine, operational. This means that it has valves and ports that are
pretty sensitive to any dirt and grime, and any contamination to the oil
will cause failure to these components. They install magnets in the oil
pans and a pretty good filter for this application to keep any metal
chips/contamination out of these valves. The preferred maintenance for
these machines is to not only change the oil, but to perform a flush of the
oil to insure that all old oil with spent additives is completely removed.
If it weren't for the valves present in an automatic transmission, I'm
pretty sure that those cheap guys in Detroit would only use one oil in their
machines, engine oil.
The ATF and motor oils used today have come a long way since they were first
introduced. The additive packages do a much better job in protecting the
oil from that heat and water in any form.
The PSRU's that you are talking about do not seem to have any valves
associated with them. Therefore, I'm led to the conclusion that motor oil
should perform just fine in this application so long as you install magnets,
filters, and heat exchangers prudently. If you want my best recommendation,
I would suggest that you change the oil on a more religious basis.
Remember that the additive package is designed to protect the oil from HEAT
& WATER in any form. The shearing loads that you are talking about with
these gears generate heat. That breaks down the additive package.. When
you park this machine after heating up the unit by running the motor, this
hydroscopic stuff will absorb water from the atmosphere as it cools down (
yes, the oil will absorb water) . That breaks down the additive package.
Your only defense against breaking down the additive package is to change
the oil. Adding a new quart is a bandage to replenish the additives and
does not flush out the acids that the heat and water form.
I am interested in the facts about how often you have been changing the oil
in these machines. If you are doing this portion of your maintenance, then
I'm more inclined to believe that the area that you need to focus on is the
potential hardness of the gears that you've mentioned. I don't believe that
Ford uses any hardness altering methods in the assembly process of their
transmissions.
I also believe that if the oil was the problem, you would be seeing a
general failure of all components involved. Since the pictures show only 1
or 2 components affected, I would question the assembly practices and the
hardness/integrity of the failed components.
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org