> > 100% ethylene glycol cools WORSE than 50/50 EG/water mix.
There is a LOT of snake oil out there. I am not saying that NPG is
snake oil, really haven't looked into it, but it is likely not optimum
for
cooling engines designed for EG/water 50/50 mix.
So far as I know, no commonly available liquid has a higher specific heat
value than water. Even mixing antifreeze with water effectively lowers
the
amount of heat the coolant can absorb as anitfreeze does not have as high
a
specific heat value as water. So regardless of the boiling temp of the
cooling liquid, if the specific heat value is lower then less heat is
transported from the metal into the liquid per unit volume.
I have run propylene glycol piston engines for over 15 years and my
rotary coot for over 900 hrs and would never consider running
anything else. I have just switched to Evans coolant and have about
60 hrs on it and like it so far it boils at 370 degrees at 0 psi and
has 27 percent better heat transfer than water with a wetting agent.
I know rotary road racers that run Evans and say it has stopped the
cracking around the spark plug. The only down side I can see is it
costs 25 bucks a gallon but if it works I think that is cheap.I will
let you know how it is after I get more time on it.
Thanks for the expert advice guys. Once again the value of this group is
demonstrated by people willing to share their knowledge and experience. Even
though there may some disagreement, this group usually handles it
professionaly rather than resorting to flame wars.
The reason I originally introduced this topic was to see how much actual
experience there was in the usage of NPG and to get any feedback on its
value. Unfortunately, it seems that only one person seems to have actually
used it in a flying rotary. Although he seems to be getting positive
results, I don't think that is enough to give me confidence to try it on my
own. Maybe by the time my airplane is ready to fly there will be more data.
I am going to be fussy about getting my cooling system right since I cooked
my lycoming in the Arizona heat. I would rather go a little overkill and
sacrifice a little performance than live right on the edge. As far as I
know, before I started my project, no one except Perry Mick has done a
LongEZ rotary with the pan down. So I am already walking in some fairly new
territory.
Dick Gregory
LongEZ N613NC
"pan down"??? Is that opposed to plugs up? :-)
Tom Jordan is flying a Long Ez in the midwest with a super charged rotary
and Greg Richter is flying a Cozy with a turbo charged rotary. Both are pan
down.
In any event the coolant temp coming out of the block and the boiling
temp of the coolant is of little consequence if the metal is overheating.
As I said several times before guys the bottom line is the thermocouple at
the base of the spark plug. Until we get that kind of CHT data we
are pissing in the wind.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org