"Schertz, William W." wrote:
Some thoughts on coolant choices
Some time ago Evan Cooling Systems gave a talk on the Nonaqueous Propylene
Glycol (NPG), and I thought I would share a few items from their slides.
Properties
NPG 50/50 Ethylene Glycol
Boiling point 369F 212F (this can't be right,
later chart shows 224F)
Freeze point -71F -34F
Heat of Vaporization 12,500 9,800
(cal/mole)
Specific Heat 0.73 0.88
@ 121C divided by specific heat of water at 121C
Thermal Conductivity 0.22 0.54
@121C divided by that of water at 121C
Surface Tension 35 56
Dynes/cm at 25C
My Note: for good heat transfer characteristics you want HIGH thermal
conductivity and HIGH heat capacity. If either are lowered, you have to
have a greater delta T or a higher flow rate to accomplish the same heat
transfer.
What do they propose as the advantage of NPG? Their pitch was primarily for
diesel trucks.
1. Low pressure system, resulting in lower cost components
2. Smaller radiators (my note: dependent upon higher temperature of
operation)
3. More energy of the fuel going into producing work, improving the BSFC
(again because of higher temperatures)
Can these be accomplished? Yes, IF you can run the system at a higher
temperature. They ran some comparison tests and increased the temperature
from 200F engine coolant out with EG, to 260F engine temperature out with
NPG and achieved an increase in efficiency.
Can we do this? Not with the rotary, my understanding is that this would be
hard on or destroy the seals.
The other item that is buried in their data is that they increased the
coolant flow rate substantially to keep the engines from having local hot
spots (up to 71.9 gal/min for a diesel truck engine) The flow rate of
EG/H2O could not be increased to those levels at those temperatures, because
of the vapor pressure and the propensity to form steam bubbles which then
flash over into steam pockets.
MY conclusion,
Yes, NPG under the right conditions, in an engine that can operate at the
higher temperatures can have some advantages, but with the limitations of
the seals in the Rotary, I will stick with a normal EG/water mixture, use a
pressure cap, and attempt to make sure that the engine never gets to the
temperature that causes steam pockets.
Paul, you are right that we really won't know all the margins until someone
measures down at the wall surface, but that is a little more research than I
am prepared to do on my engine.
Another point on the heat transfer near the sparkplug area - the accepted
wisdom of grooving the housing was developed for EG/water mixes, and I
believe that the grooving provides more sites for incipient nucleate boiling
(the good kind) for rapid heat transfer (more sharp corners). With the
lower thermal conductivity and heat capacity of the NPG, the grooving may
have little or no effect. (increased turbulence could help, but would lose
the nucleate function)
Bill Schertz
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org