Second fragment of new EAA article.
OK guys have at it.
Tear it apart.
"This is a bit subtle and concentrated so it will take some
cogitation and re-reading for this to sink in.
We will define heat flux here as the rate of heat transfer per
square inch of transfer surface. HP is a force times a velocity, or
put another way, force times a distance traveled per second.
Since watts (heat) and HP are interchangeable (746 watts equals one
HP) if your engine has 20 square inches of combustion chamber
surface to transmit 100 HP worth of waste heat that is easier to do
than transferring 200 HP worth of waste heat with 20 square inches.
Related to this is the HP per cubic inch displacement of the engine.
The higher the continuous HP per cubic inch the more severe the cooling
problem.
Temperature gradients in the metal are also very important. A temperature
gradient is defined here as a rapid change in temperature from one
part of a solid to another. High temperature gradients lead to
cracking as part of the solid wants to expand and this expansion is
resisted by the cooler parts.
This is the very crux of the situation in getting the heat out of
the metal and into the coolant when dealing with high continuous HP
per cubic inch engines.
In a typical water cooled automotive type engine the water jacket
inside the cylinder head is inaccessible. You can not open up the
head and make modifications and improvements to the water jacket.
Fortunately this is not the case with a Mazda wankel engine. The
rotor housing is a separate part and when the engine is unassembled
the interior part of the rotor housing water jacket is readily
accessible for modifications. In fact several modifications have
been tried such as grooving the walls of the water jacket to improve
the heat transfer from the metal to the liquid coolant. We have
discovered that this is unnecessary if you limit your engine to around
200 HP for take off and cruise at 175 HP. However this feature may
come in handy in the future when we get more experience with higher
HP turbo charged Mazda two and three rotor engines.
Once boiling of the coolant starts it is all over. Things go to hell
in a hand basket very quickly indeed. This is what I mean by an
unstable cooling system. Forget all you have learned about car
overheating. You cannot just quickly reduce power and pull over to
the side of the road and stop. A few experiences like this during
climb out can be very discouraging indeed. Many people have given up
on water cooled aircraft engines at this point. It takes an extra
amount of perseverance and determination to continue.
Having said that it is best to test your new water cooled airplane
at low use, uncontrolled airport so you can get it back on the ground
right now! Otherwise you may damage your engine.
It is also best to suppress your creative urges and copy some system
that someone else has used and that you know works. Later on, after
you have flown your airplane for awhile, you can do a little creative
experimenting."
Paul Lamar
I'm brand new to the list and still don't know much about Wankels, but
here is my 2 cents on the article section:
The increasing heat levels as a product of "more horsepower," are more
directly (and easier to calculate) the product of more fuel burn per
unit time. That is the primary source of heat. I'm sure friction and
metal compression effects are included but they are a very small
percentage.
Regarding cooling, I can think of several contributors to the mentioned
problems:
1) air circulating in the system due to the radiator or header tank NOT
being placed above the engine (some say at least 8 inches).
Out of the question for most aircraft. Even the P51 did not have the header
tank eight inches above the engine. Most modern cars do not have the header
tank eight inches above the engine. I admit it sounds good as the pressure
in the system will be enhanced slightly. This is minor effect however compared
to changing the pressure cap from 16 psi to 24 psi. PL
2) induced cavitation due to improper design of the flow regions, with
their not being able to accommodate the increased flow rates.
3) insufficient contact area between the metal and cooling fluid (most
probable?) The engine's small size may be self limiting due to (or lack
of) cooling effects. If this is true, the only solution I know of is to
change to an exotic cooling fluid. Read: higher cost and complexity.
Water is just about the best medium I know for heat transfer, but there
are others available that are a little better. I'd have to dig out my
chemistry books to be sure, but the others were all expensive, plus each
had major disadvantages like causticity, and etc.
HTH,
AI Nut
(posted at the bottom per request)
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org