Subject: Vne - was "plugs up/lack of"
From: ACRE NL
Date: 8/26/2001, 5:57 PM


<<<snip>>>

Monty

Klause is going over 250 with a Varieze but he has discovered some things
along the way. I am sure Herb is aware of them. Klause is also very
fond of beefing things up with carbon.

Paul Lamar


 Exceeding VNE (V *never exceed* !!!) is a VERY risky proposition.  The Berkut
used carbon fiber all over the place and the much higher stiffness and lower
weight
of the carbon will help a lot with this problem.

I'm not an aero engineer, but this is aero-structural interaction and I have
studied it
a bit.  Any real aero engs out there please correct this if I get it wrong.
Apparently
the biggest issue is flutter of the aero surfaces (wings, horizontal stab,
fin)  The
natural vibration frequency of a vibrating object is proportional to (K/M)^0.5
which is the square root of the stiffness (K) divided by the mass (M).  So, to
increase the natural frequency (where flutter can occur), you need to increase
K (stiffness) and/or decrease M (mass).   Carbon is about 3X the stiffness of
glass, so this is very helpful when trying to increase the Vne of an
existing design.
Substituting carbon for glass increases K.  Since most carbon is also
stronger (note
that stiffness and strength are NOT the same, nor are they particularly
closely related)
than glass, you can use less, so you may also decrease M, also good.   This
just tells you
about the general direction you are blindly wandering in - generally towards
death and
destruction or generally away.   Not good enough in my book.   Test pilots
make the big
bucks by going out and finding out whether the calculated Vne is actually
safe.  If you get
it wrong, the pieces are usually scattered over a very wide area.  You
really need to do
a proper ground vibration survey (needs smart people & expensive equipment) to
find out what the whole surface flutter situation is going to be like.

This is very dangerous ground to be working in without proper knowledge.  A lot
of "eyeball engineering" will work just fine up to about 150, perhaps 200 mph.
When you start looking 300 mph in the face, the rules are changing and the laws
of physics are extremely nasty.

Remember the famous saying of one of the 20th century's great philosophers -
Harry Callahan:  "A man has GOT to know his limitations."

My saying is "The laws of physics will be strictly enforced"
 . . . .and they'll kill you in a heartbeat without remorse.

Ya'll be careful out there in the "experimental" part of the flight envelope.

Bill Freeman
Long EZ builder & pilot
BSME, MSME
EAA Technical Counselor

I don't know if the group is aware of some of the downsides of using
only carbon fiber, brittleness being one of them.  Just throwing my 1
cent in to be on the safe side.

AI Nut

That does not appear to be a problem unless you crash.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org