<snip>
There is nothing left in Afghanistan to destroy or bomb.
It would be a waste of money.
It will need to be done with ground forces.
Paul lamar
Monty Roberts wrote:
I hope not Paul. Afghanis and the terrain are tough as nails. Mountains are
no good for armor. Light infantry only. The Afganis have only been conquered
by the Mongols under Genghis Khan. He killed them, arranged them feet to the
inside, heads to the outside in circles, stacked in layers and plastered
over. Left many such monuments 20-30 feet high. Unless we are ready to be
this ruthless, putting conventional troops on the ground would be a
disaster. Better to seal the borders, bomb all installations (such as they
are) and means of supply. Supply the revolutionaries in the country with
weapons, food, medicine and advice (special forces) and air support. Starve
and isolate the Taliban forces. Let the locals take care of the problem.
As to the aircraft carrier. Pakistan has nukes. They claim to be on our
side, but I don't think we can trust them. Carrier battle groups are rather
vulnerable to nukes. What we need is a submersible nuclear aircraft carrier
with some good long range subsonic ground attack aircraft ala A-10 or
frog-foot. Of course a nuclear depth charge is a problem, but you have to
find it first.
Really I think that we are in a situation where our technology is somewhat
useless. This is going to be assassinations, human intelligence, special
ops, and bloody ground conflict in certain areas. Civilian casualties in the
US will continue. Due to the lack of a big WWII style buildup and wartime
economy, the US and world economy will suffer greatly. It is going to be
ugly. I am already having problems with some of my projects because of this
thing. I hope that I am completely wrong, but I fear I am not.
Sorry to get off subject, but this is probably one of the few rational
groups in the country with which to discuss this kind of thing.
Monty
I am not so pessimistic. As a friend of mine said "the next time
somebody tries to hijack a plane with a pocket knife they will
be rushed and beat to death by fifteen or twenty passengers."
The days of racial profiling are also upon us. Nobody likes to
admit that but I am sure it is true. There will not be any more
arab guidance systems in B767 cruise missiles.
I am no infantry general but I think we should get in and get out
with a ground strike force before they can mass any troops.
That is where the C130 comes in. Trying to subdue the population would
be suicidal I think. Like you say we would have to kill them all
down to the last man women and child.
Here is my scale sketch of the C130 aircraft carrier. It is not a sub marine
but it does float on submerged pontoons. Reduces the pitch in a sea way
so it is easier to land and takeoff.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org