Paul: As long as we are thinking. Take the pontoon aircraft carrier a
step further. Let it be powered by a couple of "mothballed" subs. Would be
able to submerge the subs and come up into a "harness" that would allow them
to be used for propulsion. Neat escape device as well if under severe
attack.
Lloyd
Not a bad idea. Might work if you could get rid of the weight of the
Polaris missile
and torpedo tubes. It sure would be quicker to build.
How long is a Boomer Tom?
Paul Lamar
Tom Kendall wrote:
Early to mid-cold war US boomers were about 32' inside diameter (sorry all
you SI folks, all US Navy vessels were built to customary "Christian" units
;-) ) and about 310' long. Late in the cold war, some of these boats were
retro-fitted to become special operations boats supporting (among other
things) covert SEAL team deployment and recovery. Neat stuff. Because of
the SALT treaties, the missile tubes had to be de-activated (too many
launchers at sea, and these boats were getting pretty obsolete anyways).
But the expense of cutting out the entire missile compartment section of the
hull was excessive and didn't really add much to the capabilities of the
vessel. So the missile support systems were ripped out and the tubes
remained. This created a lot of extra usable space (both in the missile
compartment, missile control center, and in the tubes themselves). For
weight and balance reasons (remember folks, submarines fly too! They just
do it in a denser medium), several of the missile tubes were filled with
concrete ballast cannisters. The remainder could be used for stores,
munitions, lock-in / lock-out modifications, etc. The missile compartment
was converted to extra berthing, and the ships were then capable of
deploying with very large complements (we got underway with upwards of 150
people) for extended periods.
Later boomers (some of which may now be nearing de-activation age, if not
already deactivated due to military scale-backs) were truely HUGE. Over 400
feet long and IIRC 4 decks high... must be over 45' diameter. One of these
babies retro-fitted should be able to sustain crews of over 250.
But I really doubt that simply harnessing these to a surface vessel would be
practical. The "harness" would have to be absolutely rigid, and capable of
withstanding extremely high forces (analogous to an engine mount in an
aircraft). At the same time, it would have to be "quick release".
I think the quick escape option is out of the question. Getting people into
and out of a submarine is problematic in any case (how many people can you
get to climb up/down a ladder and through a 24" hole in a minute?), and
certainly not something you want to try to do in an emergency. We had
"escape hatches" at each end of the boat, but as recent cold war revelations
have shown, these weren't really for emergencies. That was a convenient
cover story that made Mom feel good. Sure, they could be used for that in
the unlikely event a sub went down on the ~2% of the ocean bottom that was
shallower than crush depth. There is a reason submarine sailors get
hazardous duty pay. If anything goes seriously wrong, it is a one-way trip
down, and all Mama gets is a folded flag and survivor's benefits. No dead
stick landings. No parachute.
Torpedo survivability: The Soviets went a long way on this one. Their
naval architecture always tended toward the bigger, heavier, more armor
school of thought. Part of the reason was because metallurgy was a low-cost
technology, whereas "high tech" electronics, power plants, and signal
processing (all essential for very effective weapons) were beyond their
practical means. They built very heavy, sometimes "double" hulls in an
attempt to make a vessel one-hit proof. Their weapons were relatively
simple and crude, but built to deliver a huge punch, something that would
have easily taken out one of their heaviest vessels. Odd how our weapons
tend to be designed to defeat our own platforms.
The US never did that. We had no delusions that a submarine (or most ships
for that matter) could survive a hit from even a single modern torpedo.
Rather, we designed for speed and agility, stealth, and a capability for
jamming and decoying incoming torpedoes. Modern torpedos contain a shaped
charge in the head that blows a hole through the hull of a submarine... end
of discussion. Shock and concussion are secondary to getting water in the
people-tank, but probably just as lethal. Interestingly enough, the same
warheads and homing electronics are configured against surface targets to
run *under* the hull and detonate some distance below it. The resulting
lifting force on the spine of the ship, followed by the quick drop back into
the "hole" in the water beneath it breaks the keel and literally breaks the
ship into two pieces. I've watched videos of testing on decommissioned
hulks, and it is truely impressive. Nothing short of a very large and heavy
battleship (and there aren't many any more), or an aircraft carrier can
withstand that kind of punishment. The pieces go down quickly.
No, the best strategy against torpedos has been to 1) prevent their launch
2) out maneuver or jam them. Once one hits, it's just a matter of who
manages to get over the side with a life jacket and without having their
innards jellied by the initial shock or getting fried in the resulting
fires. Ugly fact of naval warfare. The way we currently do this is by a
defensive screen around carrier battle groups that is supposed to prevent
hostile submarines from getting within striking distance.
But... there aren't a whole lot of brushfire war adversaries capable of
obtaining, deploying, or effectively launching a modern torpedo. So perhaps
this is all academic in the post cold war era.
Attachment of flight deck / superstructure to hulls: A long thin connecting
keel is actually better hydrodynamically than multiple struts, and, if
fabricated correctly, would be at least as strong an attachment. As
discussed above, the issue of torpedo resistance is probably irrelevant.
Old subs: Some old submarines are moth-balled. We called them the "dead
boats", and they were all rafted up together in various shipyards. Used to
go over and ransack them for spare parts when I was on an aging boomer. The
old reactor cores are off-loaded and shipped for long term storage in a
remote inland location (the Soviets just deep-sixed them... in the world's
oceans). Others were converted to training platforms for budding "nukes" to
learn how to operate the reactor plants. Last I heard several of these were
still operating in various locations. These probably cannot be easily
re-commissioned due to limitations on the hulls and support systems. The
rest have been reduced to razor blades. The hull steel was real high
strength, high quality stuff, so I'm sure the recyclers paid top dollar for
them. The US hasn't done a very good job of moth-balling decommissioned
vessels since WWII. Hasn't seen much value in it.
IMHO, it would actually be faster, cheaper, and easier to build brand new
reactor plants than to restore a decommissioned ones to useful service. We
are still building reactor plants (although far fewer now than in days gone
by), and have the capability. Older plants, particularly those that have
not been maintained for a while, would be a nightmare of certification
testing, paperwork, contamination problems, etc. The aerospace industry has
nothing on the nuclear world (naval or otherwise) for Quality Assurance
requirements and bureauocracy. The task would be comparable to having P&W
come up with a variation of an engine vs. restoring a long out of production
(and out of maintenance) engine and successfully having it certified for
commercial air transport uses.
I think that covered all the comments I saw in both Paul and Lloyd's
postings. Thanks for the chance to pontificate!
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org