Subject: Tracy EFI in CONTACT! Mag
From: ACRE NL
Date: 10/1/2001, 3:05 PM


Ed Anderson wrote:

 Latest issue of CONTACT! has excellent article by Tracy Crook on his
development of his EFI.

Ed Anderson
Matthews, NC
RV-6A N494BW
eanderson@carolina.rr.com

Tracy, can you up upload the text here?

Paul Lamar


Paul,
Most of this will be old news to the builders on this list but attached is
the text of the CONTACT! EFI article.

Tracy Crook
tcrook@rotaryaviation.com
www.rotaryaviation.com

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org

Tracy-Crook-EFIcontact.txt
Tracy Crook, Real World Solutions
						5500 NW 72 Way
						Bell, FL   32619

						(386) 935-2973
						Email :  tcrook@rotaryaviation.com
						www.rotaryaviation.com

EFI Design for Aircraft

This article will detail the experiences and design philosophy behind the EFI/Ignition controller that I developed 
for the Mazda 13B rotary in my RV-4.  I call it the EC2;  EC for Engine Controller, and 2, because it is the second 
version I came up with. 

It wasn't a distrust of EFI that led me to discard the factory system on the Mazda 13B chosen to power my RV-4.  
Modern EFI systems have proven to be very reliable and I had originally planned to use it, but that was before I 
had actually seen one.  When the truck delivered the used rotary engine I had ordered, I immediately had second 
thoughts.  After acquiring some books on the subject and studying modern automotive fuel injection systems for a 
while, I saw that the design considerations for car use are vastly different than for aircraft.  The Mazda rotary 
intake system was even more complex than most and the myriad of emission control systems alone was enough to 
discourage me.   Since space is always a scarce commodity under the cowl, the tall manifold and bulky mass 
airflow sensor didn't help either.   The final nail in the coffin was its weight of about 50 pounds. 

 Still, there were a lot of advantages to fuel injection that I reluctantly gave up when I installed carburetors on the 
engine.  The three Mikuni sidedraft carbs served me well for three years and 650 hours of flight but their 
shortcomings began to be more and more obvious.    Even though they were CV (constant velocity) type carbs that 
compensate for altitude, their ability to control the mixture was limited to about 8000 feet.  The desire for higher 
cruise altitudes and the lust for more horsepower started me thinking about EFI once again.  I am a retired EE 
(electronics engineer) with 30 years of hardware and software design experience so the task of designing one 
seemed doable.
  
PICTURE   HERE (Engine4BW.jpg)

This is an early photo of my RV-4 engine installation showing the three Mikuni carburetors.   They mixed over 
4000 gallons of fuel with air and flew over 100,000 miles before being replaced with an EFI system.

Before deciding to roll my own, I evaluated several aftermarket EFI systems but rejected all of them for various 
reasons.  Some of them require a laptop computer to setup or tune and it was (and still is) my opinion that the 
cockpit of an airplane in flight is no place to be fiddling with a PC.  It might be argued that this could be done on 
the ground, but I have found that it is absolutely critical that the system be tuned under actual flight conditions if 
best fuel economy is to be achieved.  

Another missing feature was the lack of a manual mixture control on the aftermarket systems.  When I mention 
this, many builders respond that they thought that lack of a mixture control was an advantage of EFI.  I suppose it 
is in a car, but a little study of the subject will show this not be the case with aircraft.  

FADEC -  SCHMADEC

This might be a good place to comment on the term "FADEC" which seems to be all the rage now.  Several 
companies are developing EFI systems for both homebuilt experimentals and certified aircraft that claim to be 
FADEC systems.  The term is an acronym that stands for  'Full Authority Digital Engine Control', and proponents 
trumpet its great advantage of  'single lever power control'.  The idea does have some appeal, but let's take a hard 
look at the subject.  FADEC was originally developed for high-end applications like fighter jets and rocket engines 
where reducing pilot workload is crucial.  The goal is to have the engine respond to pilot input in direct proportion 
to power control inputs and at the same time, maximizing engine efficiency. 
 
To do this requires that the engine controller have 'full authority' over all engine parameters.  In the world of 
engines we are interested in, this includes manifold pressure.  Manifold pressure is primarily controlled by the 
position of the throttle plates so if the controller is to have full authority, it must have control over the throttle.  
This means that a 'fly by wire' system is needed.  The power lever that the pilot moves is just an input to the 
controller, which in turn positions the throttle plates with a servomechanism.  
Now here's the point.  None of the so-called FADEC systems I have seen have this feature.  The pilot's throttle 
control is linked directly to the throttle plate in all cases that I have seen.  This may not seem significant at first 
glance, so let me illustrate with an example.  It will also explain the answer to why I chose to have a manual 
mixture control on my controller.

Let's say we are cruising along at 10,000 feet and our intention is to cruise at the most fuel efficient setting.  Best 
engine efficiency will be achieved with the throttle plates wide open (to minimize pumping losses) and the mixture 
aggressively leaned.  The rotary is especially well suited to this condition because there is no need to worry about 
burning pistons or exhaust valves.  

Now let's say we encounter a situation that requires maximum power, such as the need to climb over a mountain 
range or ridge of clouds.  Or perhaps we have blundered into a box canyon and desperately need to climb out 
before we hit the wall.  To get more power from the engine under these circumstances, the only option is to richen 
the mixture.  The difference in power between best economy mixture and best power mixture is substantial.  If we 
are flying one of these pseudo FADEC systems, what are we going to do?  The throttle lever is shoved as far as it 
will go already and there is no mixture control (single lever power control, remember?!)   
The bottom line is that these systems have to be programmed to give either best power or best economy or a 
compromise between the two.  You can't have both and still have 'single lever power control.'  I was unwilling to 
give up either power or economy so a manual mixture control seems like a small price to pay to get both.

MAF or SPEED-DENSITY?

After deciding to dispense with the idea of single lever control, it was time to move on to choosing the basic type 
of control mechanism for my EFI design.  There are currently two types in use.  Most automotive systems in use 
today use the Mass Airflow (MAF) scheme.   If we know the absolute mass of air that the engine is breathing, we 
can calculate the appropriate amount of fuel to add in order to get an appropriate mixture.  This approach is 
elegantly simple because we do not need to know anything about cubic inch displacement, how fast it is turning, or 
volumetric efficiency of the engine.  Theoretically, a good mass airflow controller would work on virtually 
anything from a Briggs & Stratton lawnmower engine to a Pratt & Whitney R4360 radial engine and require very 
little tuning between engines.   The downside to MAF is that the sensor required to measure airflow is rather large 
(vane type) and in the case of the hot wire type, fragile.  The hot wire type measures airflow by the cooling effect 
the air has on a thin wire, which is being heated by passing an electric current through it.  

The other system in current use is called Speed - Density, which determines the amount of fuel to inject by 
measuring several parameters.  The main two factors are RPM of the engine (speed) and manifold absolute 
pressure (density).  If we also know the cubic inch displacement of the engine, we can then calculate the 
approximate amount of fuel to inject.  The calculation is complicated by variations in volumetric efficiency.  These 
variations are due to tuning effects of the intake and exhaust manifold, cam timing and overlap (or port timing in 
the case of the rotary), and air temperature.  The temperature is easy enough to measure with a sensor but it would 
take a super computer the size of a car to compute all the other factors affecting volumetric efficiency in real time.  
Despite these apparent disadvantages of speed density, this system was chosen for my design due to the small size, 
low weight and low cost of the required sensors.  These factors were especially important because I had decided 
that redundancy was a must for my controller.  There are two of everything, including sensors.

 This problem of variable volumetric efficiency can be side stepped by using what is called a "look up table".  The 
controller performs its calculations assuming a volumetric efficiency of 100%.  For example, if a four-stroke 
engine of 1 liter displacement has turned two revolutions and the manifold pressure is 15" Hg  (1/2 of atmospheric 
pressure), we would calculate that the engine had breathed in ½ liter of air (at atmospheric pressure).  The actual 
amount would be affected by the factors already mentioned, so the controller would then refer to the look up table 
for information on how to compensate for these factors.

In aircraft applications, the manifold pressure most accurately defines the engine's operating condition.  Since the 
engine load is a propeller, if we know the manifold pressure, we also know approximately how fast it is turning.  
This is unlike a car where the engine could be at full throttle (high manifold pressure) but only turning at low RPM 
(lugging up a hill in high gear for example).  For this reason, the lookup table in the EC2 is a list of numbers 
corresponding to different manifold pressures.  We will refer to it from this point on as the MAP (Manifold 
Absolute Pressure) lookup table or "MAP table" for short.  There is one entry in the table for approximately each ½ 
inch of manifold pressure.  To illustrate, if the engine is running at 20" of manifold pressure the EFI controller 
calculates the theoretically correct amount of fuel to inject, but before opening the fuel injector it looks up the 40th 
number in the MAP table (hence the term 'lookup table') and adjusts the mixture according to the number it finds 
there.

KISS

Since simplicity is one of the factors that attracted me to the rotary engine, I decided this would have a high 
priority in my EFI design as well.  Some of the things I decided to eliminate were the throttle position sensor, 
engine coolant temperature sensor,  O2 sensor, EGR control and idle speed control.  This reduced the number of 
wires in the system to a fraction of the number used in a typical automotive installation.  In addition to making it 
simple to install, it also increases reliability.  If it isn't there, it can't fail.  The reasoning behind eliminating each 
system will provide additional insight into the design philosophy.  

The throttle position sensor is used mainly to sense rapid changes in throttle setting.  This is important in a car 
where the throttle may frequently and quickly go from idle to wide open.  There is no need to do this in a plane 
where changes in power are smooth and gradual and the engine spends 90% of the time at the same throttle setting.   
Hence, there is no need for this sensor. 



PICTURE   HERE   (EC2bd.jpg)

The simplified aircraft EFI/Ignition controller is small enough to fit two complete controllers along with switching 
relays to select the active controller on a single board.  Even the manifold pressure sensors (bottom) are separate.
 
Let the pilot do some of the work

Even though it is not good practice, a car engine is often asked to start in sub-freezing temperatures and 
immediately be driven down the road.  To give good drivability under these conditions, the automotive engine 
controller must automatically compensate for wide variations in engine temperatures.  This makes the coolant 
temperature sensor a necessity.  In an aircraft, the engine should always be properly warmed up before takeoff so 
this sensor was considered unnecessary.  Some method is still needed to enrich the mixture when doing a cold start 
so I opted for a cold start switch on the control panel.  This along with the manual mixture control allows for 
starting the engine in most any weather. It does require the pilot to do a little more than just turn the key but is still 
easier than the priming required on most aircraft engines.

More than you wanted to know about Oxygen sensors

The Oxygen sensor is used in automotive EFI to keep the engine operating at stoichemetric mixture, which is 
important for the proper functioning of catalytic converters.  Since we don't need catalytic converters, this was 
another part to get the axe.  Another benefit of loosing the O2 sensor is being able to burn avgas, which is a leaded 
fuel.  Lead impairs the functioning of O2 sensors and even with careful flight planning of fuel stops with Mogas, 
you will end up having to use 100LL avgas from time to time if you do any cross country flying.   Leaded Avgas 
will be gone in the not too distant future but for now we have to deal with it.

It is frequently assumed that an EFI using an O2 sensor for mixture control will always be running at optimum 
efficiency.  This not correct, especially in aircraft applications.  In fact, the operating point that these sensors were 
designed to operate at is almost never the point you want in an airplane.  During takeoff you want maximum 
engine power in order to minimize takeoff distance and runway requirements.  You also want to accelerate as 
quickly as possible and achieve that first 1000 feet of altitude in order to minimize that vulnerable period shortly 
after takeoff, even if it means burning an extra pound of fuel to do it.  Maximum power requires a much richer 
mixture than the O2 sensor was designed for.  Even automotive EFI controllers ignore the O2 sensor when you put 
your foot to the floor to pass that semi truck. 

Once established in cruise flight, minimizing fuel burn becomes the top priority.  This requires running on the lean 
side of peak EGT.  Proper leaning technique on standard aircraft engines is a subject of much debate.  Some claim 
that a typical Lycoming engine must be run rich of peak (ROP) in order to avoid burning exhaust valves and other 
ills, while others claim that running 50 degrees lean of peak (LOP) does no harm.  Since my standard aircraft 
engine experience was limited to the 40.2 hours spent getting my pilots license, I don't know which is true.   I do 
know that on the rotary engine I fly now, there is no limitation at all on lean running.  There are no valves to burn 
and the iron rotor is in no danger of being burned or seizing in the aluminum rotor housing. 

Getting back to our discussion of oxygen sensors, I have found that best economy is obtained at a fuel/air mixture 
well below the operating point of these sensors, which again points to the conclusion that it would be a poor choice 
for the primary mixture control mechanism in aircraft applications.  Having said all this, there is a useful function 
for O2 sensors when used with an inexpensive mixture monitor.  I used one of these to do the initial tuning of my 
EFI. This made it much easier than trying to do it with EGT readings.

More EPA Stuff

Keeping the catalytic converter happy and carefully controlling peak combustion temperatures (for emissions 
reasons) are among the reasons for the extensive control systems related to exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) and 
idle speed control.   Both functions can be dispensed with in aircraft use.   

How Many Wires?

After one look at the complex systems and wiring harness in most cars the thought of installing an EFI system is 
intimidating to many builders.  However, after eliminating all the unneeded systems and simplifying the rest, the 
job becomes quite manageable.   There are only a total of 30 wires from the controller that I eventually designed, 
and this includes the wiring to the small control panel.  Between the controller and the engine bay, there are a total 
of 12 wires needed for a typical 13B rotary installation.  All of the switching for the backup controller is done 
internally by relays to keep the external wiring simple.  The manifold absolute pressure sensors are also internal to 
the controller so the only connections to these are two manifold pressure vacuum lines connected to the intake 
manifold.  

Automatic Backup?

A frequently asked question is "Will the EC2 switch automatically to the backup controller in the event of the 
primary controller failing?"  I looked into doing this but decided against it for a couple of reasons.  First, the 
additional logic required to do it introduced possible failure modes of its own.  Second, the additional hardware to 
do it properly was more complex than the controllers themselves.  Have you ever noticed that more space shuttle 
missions are scrubbed due to failures of the failure detection system and sensors than to actual system failures?  I 
decided that the pilot should be capable of deciding if the controller might have a problem and hitting the backup 
controller select switch if necessary.  I have never had a controller failure, but I do practice my engine emergency 
procedures regularly.  You want to be able to do this without thinking when the time comes.



Use what you have

As stated before, the stock engine controller was not considered appropriate for aircraft use but many of the 
mechanical parts of the system were perfectly adequate.  The stock fuel injectors, fuel rails, pressure regulator, and 
some parts of the intake manifold and throttle body were used as-is or in modified form.  PICTURE   HERE   
(Engine stand.jpg)

Pictured here is the engine on the test stand I used during development of the EFI controller.  The intake system is 
in mostly stock form except that much of the emission control systems (about 20 pounds worth, not needed for 
aircraft use) have been removed.  Even after this, the stock intake manifold is a complex three-part assembly that 
stands up quite high.  Several (but fairly easy) modifications are required to fit it under the cowl.   The PSRU 
shown here is the prototype of the one currently flying on my RV-4.  Its development is a long story for another 
day.


PICTURE   HERE  (Fuel rail.jpg)			PICTURE   HERE	(lower manifold.jpg)

The secondary fuel rail and injector assembly was modified and moved from the stock location on the intermediate 
intake manifold to the lower manifold (shown on right)  to lower the profile.  The injectors now squirt into the 
holes formerly occupied by the secondary intake port valves.  These valves normally only open at mid to high 
throttle in automotive use.  Since the engine is always running at mid to high throttle, these valves (and actuators) 
can be eliminated.

PICTURE   HERE     (upper manifold.jpg)

As shown here, the intermediate manifold has been cut off right after the 90 degree bend over the top of the engine.  
Thinwall aluminum tubes were then bonded into the manifold and connect to the home made dynamic chamber 
(bottom).   The top of the chamber is not installed in this photo in order to show internal details.  The throttle body 
is mounted to a semicircular plate that covers this chamber. Total intake runner length should be in the ballpark of 
16 - 18" for best performance.  Some of the terms used in this article may be unfamiliar to those without rotary 
engine experience.  I publish a book (Aviator's Guide to Mazda rotary Conversion) for those looking for a crash 
course on the subject.

PICTURE   HERE     (Thrbody.jpg)

 This is the stock Mazda 13B throttle body before and after cutting away all the unnecessary metal and bracketry.  
Only 2 of the three barrels are used.  Over 4 pounds of metal was cut away.  

  

PICTURE   HERE      (Engine-L.jpg)

Here is the mounted manifold and throttle body  view from the left side of the engine.  The throttle body is fed from 
a ram-air scoop (not shown) on top of cowl.  EC2 EFI/Ignition controller is not visible in these photos because it is 
mounted on the cockpit side of the firewall to keep it away from high temperatures. There are very few under-cowl 
wires in this EFI system. Note the use of aluminum foil and thin stainless steel to shield paint and hoses near the 
exhaust headers.  

  
PICTURE   HERE      (top front.jpg)

Front view of  EFI manifold installation.  Note the bracket on the left side of dynamic chamber that is clamped to 
the oil filler tube.  This eliminates stress on the long intake runners.  Some builders react with horror to the use of 
hard lines used to feed oil pressure to the PSRU and use of automotive hoses.  Contrary to popular opinion, hard 
lines are perfectly acceptable as long as there is no relative motion between the two ends and they are supported at 
intermediate points to avoid long unsupported sections that could vibrate.  See any turbine or fuel injected aircraft 
engine for examples. My rule on automotive hoses is never to re-use a piece of hose.  If it is removed, it is 
replaced.  This installation now has about 1100 hours on it.

Test Results

The increased power was obvious from the moment I advanced the throttle on that first flight test.  I had estimated 
that horsepower would increase from 160 to 180.  Twenty horsepower does not sound like a lot but the difference 
can be readily felt in the seat of your pants.  I personally do not put much store in dyno testing for our purposes.  A 
dyno is an invaluable tool when doing serious engine development but that's not what we are doing.  If you just 
want a plus or minus 5% figure, use a software program like those available on www.bgsoflex.com (it's free) to 
estimate power.  I used this to estimate my original carbureted engine HP at around 160.  I am satisfied that this 
was close because my performance was very close to other RV-4s using the O - 320 160 HP Lycoming.  My new 
estimate with the EFI is about 180 HP and this seems justified because I can now keep up with the O - 360 180 HP 
Lycoming powered guys.  The increased HP is mainly due to increased volumetric efficiency as a result of intake 
tuning.  I am still using the same prop, so part of the increase comes from being able to turn the engine faster.  Max 
engine RPM went from 6250 to 6500 which puts my propeller tip speed at the very highest you want to use.  I need 
a slightly higher pitch prop now.

The improvement in efficiency was small but measurable at low altitude where I got a reduction of about 3% fuel 
burn at any given airspeed.  There is no free lunch of course and if I use the increased power I also get an increased 
fuel burn.  Maximum power fuel burn went from 15.5 to 18 GPH.  Climb rate went from 2000 fpm to 2300 and top 
speed at sea level increased from 204 to 214 mph.  

While top speed and vertical climb figures are good for bragging rights, they have very little practical use in 
everyday flying.  Burning 2.5 GPH to go 10 MPH faster is a waste of gas.  The real payoff was in efficiency at 
higher altitudes.  This alone made the effort worthwhile.  At 14,500 feet I got a 20% improvement in fuel burn. 
That works out to 160 extra miles per load of fuel at economy cruise!   Two factors were involved here.  First, of 
course, was the fact that I can now optimize the mixture but a second factor was that the EFI controller was 
programmed to boost ignition advance at low manifold pressures.  Later experiments with better exhaust headers 
and mufflers resulted in further improvements to BSFC.  A full discussion rotary engine exhaust systems could 
take several pages so I'll hold that for another time.

If you find yourself looking for EFI controllers, reduction drives or just looking for more information on aviation 
use of rotary engines, check my website at WWW.rotaryaviation.com.

Happy flying

Tracy Crook