Subject: Fuel fire (was Surface rads.)
From: ACRE NL
Date: 10/4/2001, 10:53 AM


Kerosene, possible.  Gasoline above about -40F or something in that
range,
basically impossible.  Essentially ALL cars have pumps in the tank
nowdays.
If there was a 1 in a million chance, about  10 cars a month would be
blowing up.
It would be in all the papers.  I am a SERIOUS safety nut {just ask the
guys
that have read my safety rants over the past few years  :-)   } but this
is not
a real issue.  We need to be safe, but also recognize where the real
problems
are and focus our limited time and funds on those.

OTOH, you can do whatever you want to, it is still a free country,
regardless
of what Osama would like.  ;-)

Bill


Strange but true, gasoline because it is more volatile, is actually less
likely to cause a problem. And now that I think about it the incidents I
remember involved jets or turbo-prop aircraft. Hot gasoline is actually less
dangerous than cold kerosene (in an enclosed container anyway)! This really
makes the Flight 800 incident explanation seem even less likely than before,
but I digress. In order to completely convince me Bill, please address the
following:

1.) While most modern autos do use in pump tanks, the fueling system is
significantly different than an aircraft fuel system. The cap seals tightly.
The tank is not directly vented to the atmosphere, but has a vapor recovery
system, which essentially catches any hydrocarbons in a charcoal canister
and then burns them when the engine is running. I'm not debating the safety
of the auto fuel system and perhaps I misunderstand the exact design (others
more knowledgeable please feel free to correct me).

2.) An aircraft has a vented tank, the vent normally oriented so that ram
air tends to slightly pressurize the tank. Lets say a small amount of fuel
is left in the tank and there is a leak around the fuel cap due to a bad
seal, or you are absent minded like me and left the cap off :-). air gets
rammed into the vent and vapor/air escape through the leak or missing cap on
the low pressure side of the wing. To make it even worse you are cruising at
14000 ft in the dead of winter. Looks to me like you could still have a
problem in this instance. Granted this is a specific instance where several
things have to happen, the likely hood of all happening at the same time is
very small.

Monty


 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org