Subject: Power to weight ratio chart
From: ACRE NL
Date: 10/10/2001, 3:24 PM


I updated this chart for an upcoming EAA Sport Av magazine
article on the Mazda rotary engine used as an aircraft engine.
Note the Mazda RX8 side exhaust port engine exceeds the power
to weight ratio of a similar HP Garret gas turbine engine.

It does this despite the fact that the fuel burn is
about 0.5 for the rotary (May be even better in the RX8.
Perhaps as low as .45) while that of the small gas turbine is
about 0.7. This is about 30% less gallons per hour for the same HP.

Paul Lamar


Paul, I was intrigued the other day when while reading Military
Helicopter Design Technology by Ray Prouty, page 29:

"Modern turbine engines can be assumed to have a specific fuel
consumption (sfc) of about 0.5 (227g) per hp/h at their continuous ratings."

Interesting.

Hans


Perhaps for high power engines. It is the small gas turbine engines in the
250 HP range
that have the high BSFC numbers.

Ask anybody with a turbo prop airplane how many gallons an hour they
burn. Anybody fly a turbo prop on here?

PW T34 is 0.7  PW300 is 0.675.  PW JFTD12A (T73P-700) is 0.7.
The PW PT6 claims 0.6.

Perhaps for really new and big 2000 HP turbo shaft engines they can
approach .5.

Paul Lamar


Paul,

Before I settled on the Mazda rotary for an aircraft engine, I studied just
about every conceivable piece of hardware out there. From time to time I
would get off the Mazda kick and go off down some road of research, and
eventually I would come back to the Mazda. One thing I looked at really hard
was the small gas turbine. I even toured a depot level maintenance facility
where they rebuild turbines and got to stand in a test cell while they did a
full range of certification tests on a 2000 shp blackhawk engine. Standing
six feet from 2000 hp contained in something about 12 inches in diameter by
about 3 ft long is quite impressive! and LOUD!! I don't recommend standing
in the plane of the rotating components!! :-).

I looked really hard at the Solar T series, which is used in the BD-5. It is
a good little engine. I also looked at the JFS-100, which is a starter for
several models of larger turbines. Unfortunately the JFS-100 is only 100 shp
and is designed for intermittent use. Both engines have very high fuel burn
rates. This is due to the fact that they have a low pressure ratio
(analogous to compression ratio in a piston engine). All of the small
turbines tend to suffer from this problem. The helicopter engines in the
200-400 shp range solve this by having several radial compressor stages,
and/or an axial pre compressor. The problem with trying to make a small high
pressure ratio engine is that the passageways that the air must go through
get very small compared to the clearances that must be maintained to keep
the rotating parts from contacting the stationary parts. These clearances
also create leakage paths which reduce efficiency. As the size gets smaller
the leakage paths are a larger percentage of the airflow path. When you
consider that area is a squared function, you get the picture. The turbines
also cannot be operated at as high a temperature as the larger engines,
because the turbines get too small to allow for cooling passages. This all
translates to lower efficiency. The larger engines do indeed have good fuel
consumption numbers, but they do it through high pressure ratios (20!!) and
hot combustion. The film cooling and such that is used results in
complexity, expense, and is simply not possible due to space restrictions in
the smaller engines.

There is fortunately more than one way to skin a cat. A small low pressure
turbine of simple design with a good regenerator will achieve the same
results in a small engine, that a large pressure ratio does in a large
engine. The regenerator takes waste heat that would go out the exhaust and
transfers it to the intake air after it has been compressed. This reduces
the amount of fuel that is needed to heat the air to the same temp.
Unfortunately, no one has built such a beast to date. It could be a truly
great engine. Combine it with a free power turbine, one planetary reduction
box and a LAEV prop and you would really have something!!

Since I don't yet have the resources to develop such a project, the other
way to get a high pressure ratio is with a mechanical compression device,
like a rotor :-). and guess what, Mazda has spent lots O dough developing
just such a compressor! Stick a turbo on it a you have a two stage
turbo-shaft with a high pressure ratio. You are just using a mechanical
compressor/turbine section rather than a turbo-machinery compressor/turbine.
In the 100-400 shp power range, if you want a cost effective high pressure
ratio that is the way you are going to have to accomplish it. If the Mazda
engine was designed with light weight in mind, I have no doubt that it could
compete with the best turbo-shaft engines on a power to weight ratio basis,
and could also beat them on a fuel consumption basis. Turbo charging and
side port exhaust also help. Imagine alloy end housings, ceramic-coated
titanium rotors, hollow, forged, high tensile steel e-shaft, side port
exhaust and turbocharging with an intercooler. If that is not good enough
for  you, make it a turbo compound engine. I think that the unexplored
possibilities for the rotary are truly great.

Monty

The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org