Subject: Power to weight ratio chart
From: ACRE NL
Date: 10/11/2001, 9:16 AM


<snip>
 Very interesting post, Monty.  I went down the same route about 25
years
ago.  I was working at Union Carbide in their Machinery Technology Group
at the corporate Tech Center.  We worked on steam and gas turbines,
mostly selecting, troubleshooting plus evaluation of alternative
machinery.
Fuel efficiency was a big deal since the price of oil had just
skyrocketed with
gas costing up to $ 0.49 per gallon. (!!)  In any case, you are the only
other
person that I have run across that correctly states why small turbines
do
and always will suck huge quantities of fuel.  I discussed this at some
length
with some turbine design guys from DeLaval (Sweden) who were down
trying to sell us a few million $ worth of turbines.

   High % tip losses, tiny blades (no cooling and poorer shape accuracy,
plus I'd
bet on Reynolds effects,too) and low pressure ratios.  Not easily
fixable.
Excellent commentary, and also why I support the use of the rotary and
diligently oppose "car engines" in most cases, with a few notable
exceptions.
Turbo compound and regeneration are neat ideas but damnably complex
which adds weight, cost and unreliablity.  A turbo [mixed-flow first
stage
compressor ;-)    ] is a pretty good idea for a rotary, less so for most
piston
motors.

I've said many times, probably before you came on the newsletter, that a
larger displacement, direct drive, air cooled rotary A/C motor would be
an
absolute world beater.  Sadly, nobody with any brains has ~$25 million
laying
around to design, develop and produce one.  Darn.

Bill


Bill,

You are right about the complexity of most of the regeneration systems that
have been used to date by the likes of Chrysler and IH. They had very
complex rotating components and the engines themselves were ridiculously
heavy and complex. What I had in mind was an overhung shaft, radial inflow
and outflow setup ala solar T series. I would not direct drive the gearbox
for obvious reasons, but use a separate power turbine instead. If you use
this setup with annular type diffusers, you can reverse the flow into a
annular static regenerator. This would have no moving parts and simplify
things greatly. It would add weight, but the preliminary ballpark calcs that
I did said that it would be more than offset by the reduced fuel load that
you would have to carry. Note that a regenerator is only effective on a low
pressure ratio engine. With a high pressure ratio the amount of useable heat
contained in the exhaust is nil.

But the rotary would probably be better considering economies of scale.
There just aren't enough of us aviation nuts to warrant spending so much
money to sell a paltry number of units per year. The direct drive Wankel is
an interesting Idea that I had not considered. Air cooling would definitely
simplify things. I had thought about air cooling using a cooling turbine on
the end of the E-shaft. I hadn't thought about the direct drive possibility
though. That would really simplify things. If you were really careful in the
design, you might be able to have no net weight gain since you would be
getting rid of so many systems, parts, water and such. The increased size
and weight of the components might be a net zero. If so, you are correct, it
would truly be a world beater.

I would counter with, Alas, nobody with $25 million laying around is stupid
enough to squander it on such a small, lawsuit rich, unpredictable market.
They may suffer from lack of imagination, but they didn't get $25 mil by
being stupid. The way to develop such an engine is to reduce the capital
required by letting people with a common interest work together (like us :-)
Forget about patents, management bureaucracies, equipment purchases,
buildings, taxes, etc etc. The cost goes down dramatically. We all share the
overhead collectively by paying for our house, the electricity, computers
etc. The management of the program can be handled virtually. The LAEV prop
is a good example of how this can work. The main thing we are lacking is a
good attorney and accountant on the team. Somebody still has to spring for
prototypes and testing, which is still a good chunk of money. Plus we can't
all quit our normal jobs. However, I am not willing to let the "flat earth"
portion of the human race put a chain around our collective necks with the
threat of lawsuits, etc. There has to be a way to do this.

Monty

The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org