I added some stuff about the certified MecanAir version.
I finally figured out how MecanAir are going to achieve that
without making the hard parts like rotor housings. I also
fixed some things that Hans and Perry brought up.
Paul Lamar
The incredible Mazda wankel rotary aircraft engine.
Copyright By Paul Lamar
Aviation head line nine years from now "Rotary Powered Racer Beats
Warbirds at Reno, 2010". Employing turbo charged twin 3 rotor engines in
the Rotary Ranger demonstrated what a low cross section, lightweight,
reliable, smooth 1000 HP engine will do ..... Ok, so it has not happened
yet, but let me convey why such a headline is not out of this world.....
There is an engine already proven which when married with the right air
frame could certainly give the old warbirds a run for their money......
"Why do engine experts seldom? Never? include the rotary engine when
discussing the merits of auto engines for aircraft use" The last two
issues of a popular kit plane magazine had nicely done articles on
assessing auto engine for such an application - but, they did not even
mention the rotary. Are they afraid to? Is it lack of knowledge, or is it
because if they did it the rotary would jump out as a far superior choice
to any reciprocating auto engine?
Let me define the criteria for a "realistically perfect" aircraft engine.
A: Reliable
B: Robust
C: Extended TBO
D: Damage Tolerance
E: Smooth
F: No shock cooling
G: Ability to run low cost fuel
H: Low fuel consumption
I: Low purchase cost
J: High HP to weight ratio
K: Compact size
L: Simple
I think the Mazda wankel rotary engine meets most of these criteria.
The wankel engine was invented way back in the 30's by Felix Wankel. I
will use the term wankel engine in the generic sense to differentiate it
from all other rotary engines. It was not before about 1950 that Dr.
Wankel was able to build a running prototype. Many companies were
interested in the engine and under took development. Among them was Toyo
Kogyo AKA Mazda Motors. Mazda installed a state of the art computerized
test facility for the express purpose of developing the engine. After a
lengthy development period Mazda started selling cars with rotary engines
in 1967. The first of the five rotary engines cars that I have owned was a
1973 RX2 bought new. It was a very zippy little car.
Many problems came to light over the years. Only Mazda persevered and
developed the engine. All but Mazda gave up. They had a strong belief and
good understanding of the superior kinematics of the engine and adopted
the attitude of never ever give up. Eventually Mazda sold over two million
rotary engine powered cars.
Poor kinematics and reciprocating motion are the bane of the piston
engine. Things stop and start up again in the other direction twice per
revolution. This causes tremendous stresses on connecting rods, pistons,
piston pins, valves, valve springs cam shafts, lifters, push rods and
crankshafts at high RPM's. Did I forget anything? The crankshaft in a
piston engine is a stress analyst worst nightmare with twists and turns
every which way.
There is no reciprocating motion in the wankel engine. Every part moves in
a circle or keeps moving in more or less the same direction. There are
only three moving parts in a two rotor wankel engine. The eccentric shaft
and two rotors. The eccentric shaft is analogous to the crankshaft in a
piston engine. Unlike a piston engine the eccentric shaft is straight
through, extremely strong and has demonstrated the ability to live in a
highly turbocharged 800 HP two rotor 10,000 RPM Mazda racing engine of
stock displacement. The bare engine weight of this engine is only 200
pounds not including the monster turbo charger and other accessories. That
is an unprecedented power to weight ratio for all but a turbine engine.
Nobody in their right mind would think of asking 800 HP from a two rotor
Mazda wankel in a general use aircraft but it might be fine for air racing
at Reno. I mention this as it illustrates the extreme robustness of the
Mazda wankel engine.
The rotors are cast iron and unlike pistons in a piston engine are nearly
impossible to melt. They can be made from heavy cast iron because they do
not reciprocate. There are no exhaust valves to melt or burn. Burnt
exhaust valves are a common problem in aircraft piston engines. No
camshafts to gall. No lifters to score. The essential valving of intake
charge and spent exhaust gases is done by the rotor moving over openings
in either the rotor housing or the end housings. This is similar to a two
cycle piston engine but the wankel is not a two cycle engine. It is indeed
a four cycle engine and like a four cycle, four cylinder engine it fires
twice per output shaft revolution.
Absolutely nothing stops and starts up in the opposite direction ever in a
wankel engine! The engine is in perfect balance just like a turbine or an
electric motor. It is impossible to perfectly balance a piston engine as
the CG of certain parts necessarily oscillate or reciprocate. The rotary
is always much smoother running than any piston engine.
The engine never catastrophically fails in the hand grenade mode as is
common with piston engines. The worst thing that can happen is an overheat
due to loss of coolant but the engine will still run and usually get you
to an airport. There is no possibility of the cast iron rotor expanding and
seizing in the aluminum rotor housing. A common problem with two cycle
piston engines. Cold pressure checking the coolant system before flight is
important and has been found to work well. High quality AN aircraft
plumbing is also called for.
Mazda was the only Japanese company to ever win the 24 hour race at Leman
France outright over all contestants. They did it with a four rotor
version of the two rotor RX7 engine in 1991. There was little or no wear
on the four rotor engine after completing and winning outright the 24 hour
race.
The other contestants included the who's who of European exotic car
makers. The next year, rotary engines were outlawed at the Leman race. It
would be embarrassing to let a rotary engine win the race year after year.
Demand for the engine might have increased in Europe forcing car
manufactures to scrap billions of dollars worth of piston engine
manufacturing facilities and piston engine parts sales and support
infrastructure.
Now a days, generally speaking in auto racing, Mazda rotaries are either
severely handicapped or only race against other Mazda rotaries as the
engine apparently has been deemed unfair to piston engines. Mostly from a
durability point of view I suspect.
The increasing popularity of the Mazda wankel engine for use in aircraft
has several reasons. Low cost is not the main reason. The main reason is
durability. The stock engine will run for many many hours at high power
with little or no wear. The FAA certification requirements are only 150
hours on the dyno with a prescribed power duty cycle test. Any Mazda
rotary engine could easily pass that test. The problem is the FAA wants to
see a quality control paper trail on the engine parts as they are
manufactured and Mazda would never agree to that. Apparently Europe has
different rules as I know of one converted German diesel auto engine that
is certified for use in aircraft. The FAA has a reciprocity agreement with
most European countries so there appears to be a loop hole in this regard.
Be that as it may there is a company in Switzerland called MecanAir that
is certifying a Mazda based turbo two rotor.
RECENT IMPROVEMENTS
The subscribers of the Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletters and others have
actually improved the durability on what Mazda accomplished by choosing more
recent, somewhat more costly high, tech material for certain parts. A ceramic
apex seal has been developed by Dr. Francisco Inanette that is so hard and
smooth it has no noticeable wear rate. Nobody has worn one out yet.
High temperature 500 degree Fahrenheit teflon encapsulated silicon water
jacket seals and oil scraper O-rings have been developed. These increase
the ability of the engine to withstand inadvertent overheating. A common
occurrence as many home builders are relearning lessons learned back in WW
II or before about liquid cooled aircraft engines. These costly materials
are not required as the projected TBO of a stock Mazda two rotor engine in
aircraft use is about 3000 hours based on the wear rate of the stock apex
seals and cruising at about 150 HP and 4500 RPM.
It has been found that mixing two cycle oil with the fuel reduces the apex
seal wear and the carbon deposits inside the engine. The ratio used is
about one ounce of two cycle oil to one gallon of gas. The stock engine
injects oil from the crankcase into the combustion chamber. This crankcase
oil, due to certain wear additives, is really unsuited to the task. The
oil injector is disabled when the engine is raced or used as an aircraft
engine.
POWER TO WEIGHT RATIO
The power to weight ratio of the stock Mazda engine is excellent. The bare
engine weighs 200 pounds despite the use of mostly cast iron housing parts.
Expensive aluminum end housings are available to cut this weight by about 50
pounds. The fire wall forward installed weight of a non turbo charged Mazda
two rotor engine with PSRU, coolant and radiators runs about the same as an
O-320 or O-360 Lycoming. Right around 300 pounds. With non stock peripheral
intake ports and no turbo charger as much as 240 takeoff HP can be had with
excellent durability.
PSRU's
Several popular propeller speed reduction units are available that weigh
about 40 pound each. Most of these are based on the Ford truck automatic
transmission planetary gear set. Ford recently beefed up this transmission
by changing the number of pinion gears from four to six making it
suitable for the three rotor or higher power turbo charged two rotors.
TURBO CHARGERS
Turbo chargers for high altitude power weigh another 35 pounds.
We don't know the HP upper limits of the turbocharged versions because
nobody has run one in an airplane for more than about 100 hours to my
knowledge. I suspect the basic engine would outlast the turbo charger.
ENGINE SIZE
The two rotor engine is downright tiny at about 12 inches wide 14 inches
high and 18 inches long less accessories. It is quite possible to squeeze a
turbo charged two rotor engine, including the coolant radiators, inside a
stock kit plane cowling. I know as I have done it with my Kis Cruiser. By
comparison the room in a Vans RV cowling is voluminous.
THREE ROTOR ENGINES Three rotor engines are available imported from Japan
and will develop fifty percent more power. Bare engine weight for the
three rotor is well under 300 pounds. I would guess firewall forward would
be about 400 pounds. More for a turbo version. Racing Beat in Anahiem CA
has a three rotor turbo aircraft engine on the dyno generating 900 HP with
about 200 hours of dyno runs so far. That of course is 300 HP per stock
Mazda single rotor displacement. The eccentric shaft in the three rotor is
the same diameter as in the two rotor and it gives no trouble. The Mazda
Leman engine was a four rotor non turbo charged developing 690 HP at 9500
RPM with exactly the same eccentric shaft diameter. Many of the other
three and four rotor parts were similar if not identical to the two rotor
RX7 engine.
FUEL CONSUMPTION
What about fuel consumption? The Mazda will happily run 100 degrees lean of
peak with no worry about burning an exhaust valve. There are none! At this
setting the EGT has dropped down into the piston engine range and the engine
is only slightly less economical than and air cooled piston engine. Tracy
Crook estimates the pounds of fuel burned per hour for each HP generated is
.47 while an air cooled piston engine is about .45. If you run the engine
at peak power full rich it will burn .65 BSFC just like an air cooled piston
aircraft engine under the same conditions. The new RX8 engine is reputed to
be much more economical. The Mazda will happily run on auto gas which
is about half the cost of aviation fuel.
COOLING
The total heat rejected by a Mazda rotary engine is only a little higher
than a piston engine. All engines have a heat balance. Heat balance is a
term for the distribution of energy contained in the fuel by burning it.
Some energy is rejected to the coolant as waste heat, some goes out the
exhaust and the rest comes out the shaft as mechanical energy. One HP is
equal to 746 watts. An engine generating about 200 HP would be rejecting
about the same amount of HP to the coolant or or about 150 Kilo Watts. This
is not unique to the wankel! All internal combustion engines do the same
more or less by only a few percentage points. A wankel engine's heat balance
only differs by single digit percentages compared to all other forms of
internal intermittent combustion engines. A gas turbine is an internal
continuous combustion engine in case you were wondering.
IS THE MAZDA ENGINE ALL PEACHES AND CREAM?
Absolutely not! You will have a considerable engineering challenge
installing one in your airplane. Overhauling the engine is trivial by
comparison. The engine itself is not the problem. Careful planning ahead is
absolutely necessary with any non aircraft engine and it helps if you can
make mechanical drawings and mockup models. You may have to design and build
many parts like the motor mount, custom oil pan, alternator mount, intake
manifold and modify the water pump inlets and outlets. As the engine becomes
more popular many of these unique aircraft parts should eventually become
available to purchase.
Strict attention to cooling details is also essential. Most installers have
trouble with cooling. Many have given up. The exact shape of the ducting to
the radiator is extremely important and sealing the cowl properly to prevent
back pressure on the radiator is also essential. The design of the cowl
flaps and the opening around the cowl flaps is also extremely important.
Wankel engines reject one third of the cooling heat through the oil so a
good oil cooler is necessary. The stock Mazda RX7 oil cooler works well.
The wankel engine is ideal for turbo charging because of the the shape of
the combustion chamber, the inherent low compression ratio and the lack of
exhaust valves. When turbo charging the engine an intercooler is absolutely
necessary to keep intake charge temperature down. High intake manifold
temperatures lead to detonation and detonation can fracture apex seals with
consequent scouring of the rotor housing and rotors. The engine will not
fail catastrophically but will still run somewhat down on power.
A good muffler is essential with a wankel as the exhaust port opens much
more rapidly than a piston engine. Supersonic shock waves are emitted. This
problem is about to go away as the new Mazda RX8 motor will have much more
gradually opening and closing side housing exhaust ports.
A turbo charger helps quiet the engine and its additional weight is off set
by the non existent weight of the mufflers that would be normally required.
Mazda built a good turbo charger for aircraft use in the 1989 to 1992 RX7
model years. Later dual turbo chargers were too complicated and less
reliable. Earlier ones just plain cracked.
When purchasing a Mazda engine for use in an aircraft it is best to buy a
running car. Many parts from the car are usable such as alternator, ignition
coils, fuel injectors, starters, oil coolers, etc., etc.. Good years are
1989 and later. 1992 and earlier second generation RX7's can be had for
under $3000. The model years 1993 and later are going for over
$15,000 as they were much more expensive and sophisticated
cars to begin with.
I am convinced the wankel rotary is the light aircraft
engine of the future.
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org