Subject: Another flying rotary Exhaust noise vs Supertrap
From: ACRE NL
Date: 10/20/2001, 3:59 PM

Peter Cowan/Lexi Cameron wrote:

->
The 3" system at the time was over 100" with two mufflers and the Super
Trap
on the end. Some of the local circle track cars run the Super Trap right
outside the passenger door. The Super Trap is actually a flame suppressor
required by the Forrest service at one time for logging equipment. It
just
happens to be a good muffler. I don't think you could hurt one, no matter
where you mount it.

Lynn E. Hanover

So here are some results:
Inside the cockpit at 5000 rpm, no baffles on the supertrap: 123 db;
with baffles on 120 db. A couple of guys in the nearby hanger noticed no
difference. Max rpm dropped by about 200.

Wow 120 db. That is noisy.

To get to the airport the plane was at so that I could fly it the rest of
the way home, I got a ride in a friend's 125hp Super Cub. Compared to this
open cockpit 123db monster, his was like a Cadillac. But even when you take
away the open cockpit problem, this is too noisy. Guys on the ground
commented on it. Anyone building up an engine would be well advised to
experience an operating machine in order to  attach the right priority to
the muffling problem. It may be as difficult as cooling for those of us who
aren't  turbo charging.

I may try using the heavy Mazda manifold. Didn't Andy Venable say he thought
it helped?
Peter.

Perry uses it with no muffler but the 5000 RPM three blade prop chops up the noise 
coming out of the tail pipe. His airplane is not all that bad noise wise although 
I did not use my noise meter on it. When I go to Tracy's flyin next week I will 
be sure to take my Radio Shack noise meter.

This is the results Tracy got with his new muffler.


Outside noise measurments:  All measurements are peak reading which occures about  45 degrees either
side of directly behind.  Noise level falls off outside of this zone.

Full throttle takeoff measured from about 25 feet away was 104 DB compared to 124 DB before.

75% Cruise power flyby at 200 feet from meter:   90 DB  (no previous data)

75% cruise at 1000 feet from meter:            70 DB        (no previous data)

Another message from Tracy.

A few days ago I flew down to pick Bruce Turrentine up in Clearwater where
he was checking out the damage on Bill Hughs 13B  (long story)  When I took
him back to catch a 757 home, one of my exhaust collector pipes started
contacting the engine mount directly bolted to the airframe on my way back
to Shady Bend.  The amount of vibration (and noise) transmitted to the
airframe from this light contact was unbelievable.  Since I didn't know the
actual cause at the time, I thought something had come loose on the
flywheel/damper assembly causing a severe imballance.  Anyway, it ended up
showing me how important the exhaust system supports were to isolating noise
& vibration from the airframe.  In addition to re-routing the collector pipe
to give more clearance, I improved the exhaust system mounts and the plane
is quieter than ever.  Surprisingly, the sound level instrument reading in
the cockpit only went down 1 - 2 DB compared to readings prior to the
collector problem.  I took off my head set to better evaluate the noise and
realized that much of the noise in the cockpit is now wind noise.  Air at
180 mph can make an amazing amount of racket.   Need to work on closing some
small gaps around the canopy.


Here are some measurements I made on Tracy's earlier setup.
Subject:       Ed Anderson mufflers
   Date:       Sun, 03 Dec 2000 07:16:52 -0800
  From:        Paul <rotaryeng@earthlink.net>

I stopped at Ed Anderson house on Tuesday near Charlotte NC and spent a few hours
talking to Ed and taking pictures of his airplane.

Here is a picture of his two mufflers.

Ed's airplane was not running at the time so I could not get
any noise measurements.

BTW the A weighted noise data for Tracy's airplane is
as follows.

30 feet away 104 db at 3900 RPM

60 feet away 96 db during takeoff.

On a high speed fly over I estimated at 300 to 500 feet
84-86 db.

30 feet away at idle 87 db.

Unfortunately I did not have time to see Finn's airplane and measure his noise level
as I flew back to CA out of Dulles and not Tampa.

Paul Lamar

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org