The Rotor Verses the Piston. By Paul Lamar
Lets analyze the motion of an aircraft piston engine rotating
clockwise at 2500 RPM. The bore is five inches and the stroke is
five inches. At the three o'clock position of the crank the piston
is moving down the bore at maximum speed. At the nine o'clock
position the piston is moving up the bore at maximum speed. At noon
and six o'clock the piston is stopped at top and bottom of the bore
respectively.
The circumference of the crank is pi times five inches or 15.7
inches. That is 1.31 feet.
Since the RPM is 2500 the RPS is forty two revolutions per second.
So the speed of the crankpin is forty two RPS times 1.31 feet or
fifty five feet per second moving in a circle. The piston speed is
therefore the same as the crank pin speed at the three o'clock and
nine o'clock positions.
Bear with me here as we are steadily getting to the point. It takes
the crank one second divided by forty two or .024 seconds to rotate
once. To rotate from noon to three o'clock it took one quarter of
that or .006 seconds. Therefor the piston accelerated from a dead
stop to fifty five feet per second in only .006 seconds! The average
acceleration is then 9200 feet per second in one second. Well now
lets see. One G is only thirty two feet per second in one second so
9200 divided by thirty two is about 290 G's!!!!!
Let's assume for the moment the connecting rod, the piston pin
and the piston with the rings weighs seven pounds. They all move
the same way the piston does. Mr. Newton said, and he seems to
be right, force equals weight times G's. The three pound piston
alone looks like 870 pounds to the rod in the form of inertial
load. Mr. Connecting rod has to push and pull that 870 pound
piston back and fourth once every .024 seconds. As far as Mr.
Crankpin is concerned that seven pound collection of parts looks
like it weighs about 2000 pounds! 290 G's times seven pounds is
about 2000 pounds of inertial load. Mr. Crankshaft says
"OUCH!". This is a simplification of course. The compression and
combustion pressure loads sometimes adds to and sometimes
subtracts from these inertial loads. I cannot imagine a piston
engine made without light weight pistons. The piston engine, as
we know it today, would not be possible without aluminum
pistons.
Metal fatigue happens when the force and therefore so too the stress
repeatedly reverses on a part. It is no wonder your aircraft engine
crank shaft and other parts are a mass of cracks at over haul time.
Its a miracle that piston engines last as long as they do. It has
taken over 100 years of development and billions of piston engines
to make them viable.
All other things being equal, like intake breathing, the HP of an
ICE engine is directly proportional to the RPM it can be run. The
wankel engine breaths extremely well at high RPM's due to to the
lack of poppet valves getting in the way of the intake and exhaust
ports.
You might surmise from this the wankel rotary is able to revolve at
unlimited RPM's because there are no reciprocating parts. You would
be wrong. The wankel rotary also has its RPM limits. Centrifugal
force rears its ugly head. The weight of the rotor spinning around
the center of the e-shaft creates a terrific centrifugal force on
the rotor bearing at speeds of 10,000 RPM or more. By the way the
turbine engine is also subject to the same centrifugal force limits
on its compressor and turbine blades.
Never the less the wankel rotary can rotate far faster than an
equivalent HP piston engine adding to its intrinsic power to weight
ratio advantage. Also this centrifugal load due to the weight of the
rotor never changes direction on the e-shaft at high speeds so a
cracked or broken e-shaft on a wankel rotary is unheard of. This is
why the wankel rotary engine designer can afford to make the rotor
out of low cost and extremely durable but heavy cast iron.
Further development of the rotor is possible of course. Better
casting techniques are used by Mazda to reduce the weight of the
rotor in the RX8 engine soon to be announced. The RX8 engine is
rated at 250 HP at 9500 RPM. Not bad for a 200 pound engine twelve
inches wide, fourteen inches high and seventeen inches long.
Rotors made from other material with a better strength to weight
ratio than cast iron may eventually be used. A more costly aluminum
rotor is possible with steel inserts in the high wear areas of the
apex seal slots. A titanium rotor is also possible. So too would be
a sheet steel rotor perhaps laser welded together.
I hope I have adequately got the point across of why the wankel
rotary is a better engine than the piston engine.
Paul Lamar
Vance Jaqua wrote:
Paul - Per my calculations, you actually understated the accelleration
loads on the piston engine crank pin. Accell is near true sinasoudal
- or r omega squared at max - perhaps a little higher as
a function of rod length to stroke (I have a fairly sophisyticated
computation of that some where in BASIC) so a 5 inch stroke at 2500
sees about 440 "G"s for about 3080 pounds with your 7 pound piston and rod.
However for a 1/2 inch offset ecccentric (you did not tell me what it
really is) at 700[0] rpm the "G" forces are about 690 "G" sinc the rotor
weighs at least twice an aluminum piston and rod) we will use 15 pounds
for over 10,000 pounds force.
I think you mean 7000 RPM. But you are wrong on the rotor forces.
The weight of the current cast iron rotor is nine pounds and not fifteen.
The centrifugal force of the nine pound rotor on its bearing is m*V^2 / r.
Assume the radius r is 0.5 inch or .04166 foot.
m is the mass in slugs.
V is the velocity around the circle in feet per second.
Circumference of the rotor's CG path is pi times the one inch diameter or
3.1416 inches or .2618 foot. Therefor at 7000 RPM or 116.6 RPS the velocity V
is 31.24 feet per second. Squared that is 973.
Weight of the rotor is nine pounds so the mass is 9/32 or .28125 slugs.
Therefore the centrifugal load alone on the rotor is .28125 times
973 divided by .04166 foot or 6568 pounds or 730 G's.
Never the less, due to combustion forces that partially cancel
the centrifugal force, the loads at 5900 RPM are way less than
this and are at a minimum according to this chart on a somewhat
smaller engine.
Given that there are less cyclic loads in this endurance limits are
usally roughly half tensile - so the rotors pin is still more highly
loaded.
I would not say it is more highly loaded as the crank pin in a Lycoming
is about 2.25 inches in diameter while that of the rotary is three
inches in diameter. The loads reverse on the crankpin while on the
eccentric shaft they do not reverse. Further more there are no great
jogs in the e-shaft such as found in crankshafts that cause high stress
concentrations. The 13B e-shaft will live at 10,000 RPM while the engine
develops up to 700 HP. Try that with a Lycoming and you would have
a basket full of shrapnel.
Both of these answers are really not all that staggering
with reasonable structural engineering, as evidenced by the relative
success of both engine types. Catastrophic failures are usually
the result of operating way out of design limits added
to a defeciency or failure in cooling and or lubrication. Special
purpose piston engines are regurally
operated well over 10,000 rpm for usable durations - even those big
"stock" V8s operate over 8000 rpm long enough to finish rather long
races.
Yes if you make the piston engine small enough it will rev to 10,000
RPM with out failure. A model aircraft piston engine revs to over
20,000 RPM. Or make it the same size and go to 12 cylinders.
The exact same scale effect applies to a rotary. If you
make a four rotor with the same displacement as a 13B two rotor
it may well rev to over 20,000 RPM. It will also further increase its
excellent power to weight ratio advantage over the piston engine.
None of this demonstrates indisputable superiority
of either design. If you rate them against success in the world market
place - the piston engine is the clear winner - conventional is conventional
because it works purty good. Vance
I obviously disagree as there are way more factors beyond the superior design
and durability of a product that determines its success in the world
market. I think the single most important factor, in the case of the wankel rotary,
are the lack of understanding about how it works and its advantages. The
next most important factor is the huge amount of manufacturing infrastructure
that would be obsolete and need to be replaced.
The use of the rotary in aircraft is expanding exponentially.
A really big event is about to happen when Tracy Crook and Dave Garber
get the twin turbo rotary 700 HP 350 MPH huff and puff finally perfected :-)
I would not be surprised if a completely successful flight did not happen
before Christmas. I will try to be there when that happens to take
pictures and report back to our readers.
Thanks Vance for your insight on engines. I greatly appreciate your effort
on this to check my calculations and improve my arguments in favor
of the rotary :-)
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org