Subject: Quiz of the month.
From: ACRE NL
Date: 11/19/2001, 11:21 AM

These are the answers I got in the order in which they were received.
I am proud of you guys :-)>

Richard White's answer came in yesterday and was right on the
money. Special mention to Byron with his insight.

Looks like I am going to have to try harder :-)>

Paul Lamar

------------------------------------------------

I have an airplane with 200 pounds of drag flying at 200 MPH.
What is the net HP coming out of the prop?
What is the engine torque?

here's my guess:

hp = thrust * velocity / 550

hp = 200 lbs * 293.33 fps / 550

hp =  106.66

Since rpm of the engine is unknown, so is torque.

Richard White.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ok Paul,

Please excuse my lack of proper units 'cause Im deployed with the marine, 
besides I'm a doctor anyway.

HP = power = work/time = force x distance / time

HP= 200 lbs x 200 miles / hour = 4000 lb miles/hr   which converts to Newtons 
meters/sec and, among other things, HP.

Here is the point of your question, torque is unknown, it depends on engine 
RPM.

HP/RPM =  Torque (times a unit conversion constant) - HP moves the plane, the 
specifics of the engine determine what RPM this delivers the hp.  Build a 
gear box to convert this RPM to the proper RPM for the prop.

I feel your pain, Paul.  Its uncanny how many times I have heard "Everyone 
knows that torque is 'more important' the HP."  Just Friday night I spent 2 
hours at the O-club trying to set someone straight.  He is just starting an 
RV-7.  He is considering installing a 125 hp deisel because the company's web 
site says the Diesel's higher torque will make the 125 hp diesel perform like 
a 180hp lyc.  ( I think I may have talked him into a 13B).

Low-end torque (HP) matters if you love that great sound of the muscle cars, 
hogs, and big airplane engines  :-)

Dave Leonard

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
200 MPH = 17,600 ft/min

(17,600 ft/min)*200 #  = 3,520,000 #-ft/min

(3,520,000 #-ft/min)/(33,000 #-ft/HP) = 106.67 HP  (delivered by the prop)

Bill Schertz
KIS Cruiser #4045

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't know the formulae for calculating hp based on aerodynamic drag (I'm 
sure its very simple). I do know that the engine torque cannot be determined 
with the information given. The engine speed is required to calculate the 
torque. I'd bet this is the point you are trying to make -- it is the HP that 
propels a vehicle at a particular speed, and the torque is going to depend on 
gear ratios and shaft speeds.

The analogy I like to use is: The motor in my wristwatch can produce enough 
torque to lift the space shuttle, given enough gearing. But it will lift it 
very, very slowly. If you want to lift it fast enough to reach escape 
velocity, you need massive amounts of horsepower.

Jon

----------------------------------------------------------------
hmmm, this all my brain could do on a monday morning....

200 mph = 17600 ft/min
17600ft/min * 200 lbs = 3520000 ft lbs / min
3520000 / 33000 = 106 HP


hp = T(ft-lbs) * rpm / 5252

106 * 5252 = T(ft-lbs) * rpm
556712/ rpm = T (ft-lbs)

know the rpm and divide to get T.

Perry Casson

-----------------------------------------------------------
OK, I'll try

200mph is about 291 fps,that times 200 lbs devided by the magic 550 is about
105-106 hp.

Engine torque- no way to tell.  If it is turning at 5252 rpm, it would be
105-106 ft lbs.

Bob Darrah

--------------------------------------------------------------------
107 hp. Torque depends on engine rpm.

Ron Pepper

------------------------------------------------------------------
200 mph = 293 ft/sec

Power Req = Thrust * Velocity = Drag * Velocity for steady level flight
= 293 ft/sec * 200 lbs = 58666 ft-lb/sec * 1 hp/550 ft-lb/sec = 107 hp

Don't know engine torque without knowing engine rpm + prop efficiency (to
get hp out of engine).

-Byron

-----------------------------------------------------------
All mailing lists seem to be slower on the weekends than
during the week.

HP = velocity * force
=200mph*5280/3600 * 200 lbs.
=58667 ft-lb/sec
=58667/550 HP
=107 HP

Torque = Power/Omega
Omega=RPM*2*PI/60
so Torque=(HP/RPM)*(550*60/(2*PI))
or Torque= 5252 * HP / RPM

--
Perry J. Mick
Duckt N7XR
http://www.ductedfan.com

----------------------------------------------------------

Paul, I get 106.66 HP.  Engine torque would depend on RPM.  
At 5252 RPM torque would be 106.66 ft-lbs. 
  

Hans Conser 



 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org