Subject: rotary power to weight ratio
From: ACRE NL
Date: 11/19/2001, 11:02 AM


  Any PSRU is less reliable than direct drive.  Part not
installed
will NEVER fail.  ;-)  Back to my wish for a large displ, direct drive,
air cooled rotary with a proper propshaft designed in.   Dream on!  But
it
is a nice dream.

Bill Freeman
Long EZ builder & pilot
BSME, MSME
EAA Technical Counselor


It would have to be a four rotor Bill as the current combustion chamber
is
probably right out at the size limits of practicality. In that case I
think
you would have a tough time equaling the current excellent power to
weight
ratio. This is intrinsically a high RPM engine.

Paul Lamar


Why intrinsically high RPM, except due to low displacement?  What about
the 21A or the huge pipeline engines?  I can't see why the size can't be
increased
and keep the "excellent" (?) [good, perhaps] power to weight ratio.

Bill
Long EZ builder & pilot
BSME, MSME
EAA Technical Counselor

I think the pipe line engine had BSFC and detonation problems with that huge
combustion
chamber. I could be wrong on this. Perhaps a sphere's surface area to volume
ratio
may get more favorable as the size increases.

I think it would be hard to make a large low speed rotary with the same
power
to weight ratio as a high speed rotary. Power of course is proportional to
displacement
times RPM. If you halve the RPM and double the displacement you will wind
up with a heavier rotary I suspect. RPM weighs nothing. With a piston engine
on the other hand high RPM is less desirable as the reciprocating loads
rapidly
increase with higher RPM's.

What do you think about this Jon?

Paul Lamar


Mark wrote>
Wasn't this discussed a couple of years ago with the conclusion that heat
rejection becomes a show stopper in a large aircooled rotary as you can't
get the heat out of the intermediate housing.?

No air cooling for sure. The question on my mind is what happens in the combustion 
chamber when it gets much larger. It was discovered in WW II that a six inch 
piston diameter was about the largest practical piston for an aircraft engine. 
Pistons larger than this were too difficult to cool. That is why we saw 36 
cylinder corn cob engines. Obviously this is not the case in ship diesel piston
engines for some strange reason. I could be out to lunch on all of this.
I need to review Taylor on this subject.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org