If you increase the temp of the coolant going into the radiator the temp
of the water coming out will also be increased all other things being
equal. That means the temp of the coolant going into the engine block
will also be higher which is not a good thing.
I agree with Tracy. (I also agree with Paul, but on a slightly different aspect!) The original post was an oversimplification. This kind of thing leads to people making snap judgements instead of working through the calculations to see the trends and effects. If you raise the coolant temperature into the radiator 1 degree you will raise the coolant temperature out of the radiator by LESS THAN one degree. The entire cooling should be approached as a system, and parametric equations could be generated to try different assumptions and conditions. That said, I'm willing to state that running the coolant through the oil pan won't work. The heat transfer on an oil to water (or EG/H20) cooler is limited by the oil side. You need high velocity on the oil side to get the heat transfer up. The oil in the oil pan is relatively quiescent (by HX standards) so there just won't be very many BTUs transferred. And the coolant will be relatively zipping through, so the temp rise will be small. (q dot = m dot cp delta T -- low q dot from the oil, high m dot on the coolant, therefore low delta T).
But I strongly encourage the party that is interested in this idea to sketch out some basic dimensions to establish flow rates and heat transfer areas, and then calculate what happens. Perhaps it can be shown that by using a GOOD oil to water HX, there is some interesting and beneficial packaging result (its just that running the coolant through the oil pan is a lousy HX). The outcome of the modeling will be instructive to everyone!
Jon Lauter
Rotary Power Marine Corporation
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org