Paul Lamar Wrote:
If you increase the temp of the coolant going into the radiator the temp
of the water coming out will also be increased all other things being
equal. That means the temp of the coolant going into the engine block
will also be higher which is not a good thing.
Jon Wrote:
I agree with Tracy. (I also agree with Paul, but on a slightly different aspect!) The original post was an oversimplification. This kind of thing leads to people making snap judgements instead of working through the calculations to see the trends and effects. If you raise the coolant temperature into the radiator 1 degree you will raise the coolant temperature out of the radiator by LESS THAN one degree.
snips.... After that the vast majority of which I agree with.
I want to deal with just this part. I agree; if you raise the temp going into the
rad by 1 degree the temp coming out of the rad will be raised by less than
one degree due to what Tracy said about the rate of heat transfer increasing.
Now here is the rub. Liquid coolant systems have very small margins of safety
before they become divergently unstable and melt down occurs.
Let me quote my article on cooling systems located on the ACRE NL
web site because I have said it all before.
"In an air cooled engine waste heat is transferred by the fins on
head and cylinders directly to the air. This is done first by
conduction and then by convection. The rate of heat transfer is
proportional to the difference in temperature between the fins and
the surrounding air. This difference, initially, is about 400
degrees. The metal surface surrounding the combustion chamber is
500 degrees and the ambient air temperature surrounding the fins
is about 100 degrees F. If the engine gets hotter the rate of heat
transfer increases. In a sense this is a stable cooling system. The
fin density or number of fins per inch of head or cylinder surface
must be such that the rate of heat transfer to the air keeps the
hottest part of the combustion chamber below the melting temperature
of the metal. Usually aluminum."
Now for a water cooled engine:
"If the temperature of the bulk coolant goes beyond the boiling
temperature overall boiling occurs of course. All hell breaks
loose and the coolant is forced out of the water jacket through the
pressure cap overflow valve by massive amounts of hot vapor or
steam. Once boiling of the coolant starts it is all over. Less
coolant, hotter metal, more steam. Things go to hell in a hand
basket very very quickly indeed. The cooling system pops like a pop
corn. Thus the cooling system becomes very unstable indeed. Something
we all have probably experienced in our cars. This is a major
difference between the air cooled engine and the liquid cooled
engine. Needless to say this cannot be allowed to happen in an
aircraft engine.
A few bad experiences like this during climb out can be very
discouraging indeed. Forget all you have learned about car
overheating. You cannot just quickly reduce power and pull over to
the side of the road and stop. It is best to test your new water
cooled airplane at low use uncontrolled airports so you can get it
back on the ground right now! Otherwise you may damage your engine."
End of quote.
Every degree you add to the water cooling system reduces this margin
of safety. It is extremely important that everyone building a liquid cooled
aircraft engine thoroughly understand this problem.
An air oil heat exchanger on the other hand does not have this problem.
It is stable as the boiling temp of oil is probably around 300 to
400 degrees and there is no pressure pop off valve with an overboard
dump hose. In light of this I would be much quicker to embrace a totally
oil cooled engine than a water oil heat exchanger.
Paul, I think we're all basically on the same page here. I agree that one should not give away cooling system margin without a really good reason. I do think that the individual proposing the cooler in the pan idea would really learn from doing the calculations and would be more convinced by the results, rather than the rest of us kind of hand-waving the idea away as impractical. On the subject of oil cooled engines, it has been tried on diesels and the big problem is that oil is a poor heat transfer medium compared to water. In a rotary, we'd be pushing the nucleate boiling regime to much hotter temperatures, hot enough that the aluminum wouldn't survive.
Jon
I agree with this.
For the new guys Jon runs a company called Rotary Power Marine that
sells Mazda based wankel engines for boats. You are very lucky indeed Jon. Boats
have an unlimited supply of cold cooling water.
BTW how are those engines doing in commercial service on the Yukon river?
I have been thinking about that lately.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org