As always, I offer a $500.00 reward to anyone who can show proof
that intake
air velocity is not important to intake system tuning.
Tracy Crook
tcrook@rotaryaviation.com
www.rotaryaviation.com
Here is a very good illustration from Taylor. This is volumetric
efficiency as
a function of Mach number (Z) for a number of actual engines with
a
number of differnt
intake manifolds and carbs. As you can see at lower RPMs the vol
eff
is increasing
hence the power is increasing as the flow increases and as the
intake
pipe length
is becoming closer to its tuned length what ever that is. As the
Mach
number goes
above about 0.45 Mach things start going down hill. 0.45 is a
magic
Mach number in
intakes and this number shows up in a lot of Taylor's work. If you
want lots
of power keep the Mach number less than 0.45 and that means larger
pipes
for more power at higher RPMs.
OK Tracy put the check in the mail NOW!!!
Paul Lamar
Paul, didn't you just make Tracey's point that velocity does matter?
Hans
Its a question of semantics. That is not what he meant, What he meant
was
air
velocity can be too low for a given RPM. I maintain that for any RPM
the vol eff will get better as the pipe gets bigger and the air
velocity
goes down. There is no question that up to a point (0.45 Mach) higher
velocity means more air in the engine as the RPM increases. That is
consistent of course with how a pump works. More RPM more air. An ICE
is just a glorified air pump of course. I think the myth got started
in the old days when you needed a lot of velocity to mix fuel with
the air in a venturi. That does not apply with fuel injection.
Several of us were sitting on Tracy's porch during the rotary round up
and Ed Anderson brought this up. I shouted: "Ed! Don't spread myths
like that!" Most people got up and walked away. Poor Ed had to sit
there awhile and listen to me rant and rave about it. :-)>
Robin took a picture.
Paul Lamar
I agree, I DID mean that air velocity can be too low (for any given
rpm).
And I agree that I thought you were saying
You said, " I maintain that for any RPM, the vol eff will get better as
the
pipe gets bigger and the air velocity goes down." Note that you did not
put
a lower limit on this assertion, i.e., lower is better. What I am
saying
(still) is that the velocity is a necessary component to high VEs.
There is no lower limit. Think how well a piston engine would breath
if there were no cylinder head or valves to get in the way.
At bottom dead center, due to the inertia of the column of air above the
piston,
the mass of air would be greater than the mass of air down there
when the piston was stationary for awhile at bottom dead center.
The VE would be greater than 100%.
Basically a peripheral port rotary comes close to that ideal.
Can't write the check yet because the data provided so far clearly
shows
that velocity IS important and if it is too low, volumetric efficiency
will
suffer.
I don't think it is a matter of semantics, I think it is a question of
relativity. How high is high? The chart you provided shows VE
improvements up to almost Mach .5 Note that this is on fairly dated
engines
and that the later engines with the highest VEs benefited from the
highest
velocities. The rotary is up in the 1.25 VE range so I'm sure the
optimum
velocity would be well above any of those in the Taylor chart. Again,
my
real point is that it is the energy in the moving column of air
(velocity)
that makes high volumetric effeciencies (in normally aspirated engines)
possible.
Tracy Crook
tcrook@rotaryaviation.com
www.rotaryaviation.com
I thought you would try to wiggle out of it.
That's OK. I will come down there and live with you for a week and you
will
have to feed me :-)>
Paul Lamar
Ok,
I don't have time to look at the news group much lately or get involved in a
long discussion, but I just had to bite on this one. I'm with Tracy. I have
tested engines on dynos, and I have also played around with pulse jets and
tuned pipes. I can tell you that velocity DOES matter. If you are tuning for
max VE you will get better results if the pipe resonates at the RPM where
you want the highest VE. It is like anything else, there is a point of
diminishing returns where the pumping losses overcome any gains from more
inertia available to drive the sonic tuning. Certain types of pulse jet
would not work without this dynamic tuning, Tuned pipes on two cycle engines
would not work etc, etc, etc. I bet if you really wanted to crawl through
the math (which I don't), you could come close to the mach .45 number by
calculating the pumping losses vs the pressure gain at the valve or port
from the pressure waves developed in the runner. What you are saying would
be true if the flow were constant and did not vary with time. But I think
you will agree that the flow in an intake or exhaust runner is not constant.
I think it is also fair to say that the pressure pulse available from a
moving column of air is greater with increasing velocity of that column.
Varying the length of the runner changes the time at which this pulse
reaches the opening to the atmosphere, and the time the reflected pulse gets
back to the valve or port. If you continue to make the runner smaller, you
will reach a point where the frictional losses are greater than any sonic
tuning gain. If you make it larger, frictional losses go down, but the
intensity of the pulses available will also decrease. There will be an
optimum size where you get the best of both worlds. Now for all out maximum
performance on an engine using a turbo at very high RPM you may be able to
do better with larger ports. The ideal lengths will be too short and pumping
losses will be more important. You will have very soggy response at lower
rpm's and the engine will be very peaky. I know we all think that low speed
performance is not important for aircraft, but I still like good throttle
response. Nothing is worse than hitting some wicked sink on final,
firewalling the engine and hearing BLUHpppp. Such an engine really needs a
variable pitch prop to lessen the chance of getting behind the power curve.
You can almost totally eliminate turbo lag by properly tuning intake and
exhaust runners on an engine (ask any good race tuner). They can't all be
stupid and totally in the dark. How else do you explain the improvement in
VE due to varying the length of intake and exhaust runners?
Monty
I'll catch you later Monty. After dinner.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org